The long range forecast calls for global warming. Climate change and new weather extremes are expected in the coming decades. In the past, people have faced climate change and adapted to it. This time is perceived to be different, because people are believed to be the cause of climate change.
The composition of the earth’s atmosphere has become something of an artifact. People, as they burn fuel, have increased the concentration of carbon dioxide to a number larger than nature alone would have done. If the earth’s climate is sensitive to the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, as some believe, then even climate and weather will become an artificial phenomenon of our own creation.
Because the anticipated climate change is thought to be of our own making, many believe we have a moral obligation to reverse it. If we had predicted adverse change as a result of natural causes, we might still be considering what to do about it. But because we are the cause, we are all the more responsible for providing the remedy.
Two things are at stake. One is our children’s future and well-being, and the other is nature. Future generations of people are valuable to us. Nature is also valuable to us. Some in our society are persuaded that nature has the greater value, because once it is destroyed we cannot repair and replicate a species. People, on the other hand, will always be with us.
If nature or nature's God destroy a habitat and a species, as often happens, so be it. We do not take responsibility for acts of God or for what nature does. We act to defend ourselves and the things we value from nature's depredations, but our sense of responsibility ends there.
But if our actions cause the destruction of habitats and species, as they often have, increasingly we hold ourselves responsible. No other creature has such a sense of responsibility. No other creature has an imagination that can look into the future and foresee the consequences of its actions. Our sense of responsibility is one of the characteristics of people that set us apart from nature.
In the past, people have adapted to climate change with higher dikes, different crops, and mass migrations. Seldom have we even attempted to control the weather, much less the climate. In the present circumstance it seems highly unlikely that we will succeed in mitigating adverse climate change, even if it is caused by our own activity. Never in the history of the world have all the world's people accepted major economic sacrifice and constraint to avoid unpleasant consequences that may or may not obtain in 50 or 100 years.
Economists and scientists and engineers can specify the measures that must be taken, but leaders and politicians cannot persuade the people to accept those drastic actions.
We are taking a different tack. If the problem is an excess of carbon dioxide, we will take measures to reduce our production of carbon dioxide. We can make a list of things that are feasible, technically and economically and politically, to cut back. Our goal is to cut back. We can set quantitative goals, and we can measure the magnitude of our cutting back. We do not address the question of how much climate benefit these actions produce in the long term.
People can be persuaded that cutting back is a good thing, and indeed there are other reasons to reduce our consumption of the fossil fuels that produce carbon dioxide. But the full set of measures that might actually mitigate global climate change has been compared to an effort like World War II industrial mobilization on a global scale, sustained for 30 years. The world has not been persuaded to attempt the full set.
Individuals do what they want to do, if they can, and for a variety of motives. No political authority or structure can persuade a large majority of people to do what they do not want to do; or at least not for long. So the pertinent question is how individuals can be persuaded to take responsibility for their actions in this context. Many are working on this lesson. Schoolchildren are being taught to pay attention to their carbon footprint. Some are taught that God is pleased by the sacrifices that will reduce your carbon footprint.
Some important questions lurk in the background. First, the reasonable things we as individuals can do to trim our carbon footprints will not be enough to bring about a reversal of whatever climate change we may be causing, just as loving our enemy will not bring about world peace.
Second is that perceived and very troublesome tradeoff between saving nature and saving children. The Christian faith declares that God assigns a high and irreducible value to every person. This is not a scientific discovery; it is a revelation of the mind of God. Moreover it is a truth widely held, like the revelation that life is good. If people see their choice as between nature and their own children, or any children, they will choose the children, and rightly so.
The global warming question is still before us as an unresolved issue.
Tuesday, May 30, 2028
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
