Thursday, May 23, 2041

Ten. What is truth?

Speculation on the past, a narrative about What Happened, if offered by a serious student of the past is called a hypothesis. Some people may receive a particular hypothesis as plausible, and others will reject it as implausible or impossible. (A larger third group will be disinterested). An individual receives a hypothesis if it fits into the established framework of his outlook. He receives it particularly well if it tends to strengthen and expand that framework. And people are likely to reject a hypothesis that does not fit. We express these reactions informally by saying I believe that could be true, or I believe that is not true. From statements like these we learn something about another person’s outlook. Notably we do not learn whether the hypothesis is true.

Scientific discipline approaches a hypothesis more formally. Scientists communicate with each other. If all observations support a hypothesis, and if those observations are each verifiable, and if observations could refute the hypothesis but do not, then the scientific community might agree to elevate the hypothesis to the status of a theory. The hypothesis lives in probationary status until it is discarded when observations refute it, or until there are confirming observations judged sufficient to qualify the hypothesis for promotion to the higher status called theory.

In biology, hypothesis and theory seem to be narratives about What Happened, in the past and up to the present moment, whether in a time scale of growth and metabolism and reproduction, or in the much longer time scale of evolution. Events occur coarsely in populations of organisms, or in the structure and function of organs and organisms, or in the fine details of molecules and mutations. Biologists might make predictions, but predictive theories in biology are not fundamental. Prior cause and effect are fundamental. Truth-seekers in biology look for complete and accurate narratives of past events, up to and including a complete description of the current generation. Historians and cosmologists share this perspective on the characteristic quality of truth: It really did happen.

In contrast, physics and chemistry tout predictive theories. The observable principles of chemistry are thought to derive from the more fundamental laws of physics. The laws of physics are thought to be imperfectly known, yet they are reliable in their current form as predictive theories. Truth-seekers in physics look for the more complete and more elegant statement of principles governing the behavior of all matter everywhere, past, present and future. This is arguably a different category of truth than the true narrative of events.

The laws of physics are discovered by careful observation of the behavior of the matter they describe. One might expect that laws thus derived would be merely empirical. But historically some of the great discoveries of physics have displayed that quality called elegance that almost compels a higher estimate of their origin. Discovery of the laws of physics can be compared, somewhat poetically, to the discovery of rare jewels in the bowels of the earth, or in Newton’s metaphor, among the stones on the seashore. The jewel-like quality of elegance perceived by physicists is in the purity and generality of the mathematical expression of the laws they discover. Where this elegance is lacking, physicists perceive that their work is not finished.

Physicists do not claim, or at least not unanimously, that the laws of physics exist independently of the matter they describe. Newton’s elegantly stated laws and their elegant refinements came into existence when and where time and space and matter, or something more fundamental, came into existence. To claim otherwise would seem to assign the origin of the laws of physics to the mind of God, which is currently unfashionable. But physicists do claim that the laws of physics are discovered, not invented, by people. The laws of physics were a reality from the beginning in the expanding universe. And if the laws are supposed to be mutable, the reality they describe was also mutable.

Observations in physics have outpaced elegant interpretations. The fine tuning of the universe, as certain coincidences are described, appears to be inelegant, improbable, empirical and contrived. Moreover, the cosmos at very large scale is not behaving as current theory would predict. Physicists seek more complete, more elegant, more fundamental, self-confirming mathematical interpretations of observations. The search for beauty continues in the deep mine of string theory.

The ancient Greeks investigated vibrating strings, and discovered surprising relationships between number and harmony. Simple integer ratios in the lengths of strings produced the sounds most pleasing to the ear. Integer ratios also emerged as fundamental in their studies of geometry. The relationships between observation and theory and number had that quality of beauty or elegance which was associated then and now with the discovery of truth.

Medieval astronomers were motivated to find meaningful numbers and ratios in the orbits of planets. A discovery of pure and simple integer ratios would be evidence of harmony in the design of the heavens – the music of the spheres. Harmony, simplicity, beauty and elegance would be evidence of truth. Reason rejects the alternative; that such a discovery could be a meaningless coincidence.

Astronomers did not find the harmony they had sought. Instead, Kepler and Newton discovered that the orbit of planets is an ellipse, and that the ellipse derives from the law of gravity. The truth proved to be in a way simpler and certainly more elegant than the ancients had supposed.

Modern physicists have a similar motivation. Hope is invested in a string so small as to be imaginary. Yet the harmonious characteristics of a particular string, even an imaginary one, can be derived mathematically. If the numbers associated with the vibration of the string are precisely similar to numbers associated with the observed fine tuning of matter in the cosmos, the mathematical statement about the string will be an undeniably elegant, and therefore a presumably true statement of the laws of physics. The imaginary string need not be a reality, but the mathematical statement that describes the string must also describe observable reality in precise analogy.

String theory is faltering, and may prove to be as unsuccessful as were alchemy and the search for the music of the spheres. If the pattern of the past is repeated, string theory will be swept aside by a new, brilliant, elegant insight of an imaginative person who studies observations.

If the laws of physics are a second category of truth, after the true narrative of events, pure mathematics would seem to be a third category. We do not claim that mathematical truth, two plus two equals four, is conditional upon anything whatsoever. If the laws of physics are tied to a physical universe, mathematical principles are not. In mathematics, truth exists apart from matter.

More on truth