Monday, May 28, 2035

Sixteen. Racism in America

Historically, racism in America is the claim or attitude or practice of white superiority. Ask white people of earlier centuries why they claim to be superior, and they answer with a comparison of the various features of what we now call culture. Race was linked to culture, and individuals were indelibly linked to one race and culture or the other. Western culture, or some local manifestation of it, was deemed to be superior to the culture of the other; however that other might have been perceived and described.

The origins of racism are probably as old as the competitive, belligerent, ethnocentric impulses that have made people what we are. Race and racism were preceded by culture and xenophobia. Racism did not first enter the language as an intellectual proposition of superiority. Rather, racism captures the historical reactions of people of a stronger culture to those of a weaker culture. Racism became deeply rooted in America with the importation of slaves, and racism was later institutionalized and defended with various arguments.

The challenge to racism in America has rested heavily on five words, “All men are created equal.” The words were written decades before the challenge was heard, and written in a different context and for a different purpose. We have repeatedly returned to the same words and assigned new meaning to them, in our grappling with emerging issues. These five words have found great utility in the American experiment. Their claim is widely accepted here. A hasty analysis would understate the power of the rhetorical declaration of equality in today’s society.

The claim of equality does not derive from scientific observation and discovery. Equality is described as self-evident. Other cultures have laughed at this claim. But Americans have explored and rejected the logical consequences of claims to the contrary. Our outlook, individually and collectively, is formed around the premise of equality.

Blatant claims of racial superiority have recently become quite rare here. Equality before the law is aggressively enforced. Race and culture are distinguished intellectually, yet strong correlations remain in fact.

Current questions focus on culture. Are all cultures created equal? If not, which are superior? If the dominant western culture is (arguably) the greatest source of historical injustice, should it not be at the bottom of the list? And if western culture is elevated because of its achievements, is that not a dangerous regression to the old racism of white superiority?

If all cultures are equal, truth suffers immediately. Which cultures will say, for example, that all men are created equal? That hard-won principle with its ramifications is a product of western culture, and is rejected by many other cultures. Even the truth-claims of science will be perceived as coming from a culture that seeks to elevate itself above the others. Elitists will stake out their own narrow set of affiliations and values, and then declare all other sets to be equal to each other and inferior to theirs.

What should be the attitude of an anthropologist toward the culture he discovers in some remote place? If the discovered people are primitive and brutish, can their culture be improved by exposure to a society farther up the list? Or if the discovered society appears to be uncontaminated by exposure to western influence, is that evidence of its superiority? Should the primitive culture be preserved in its remote habitat like a species of butterfly, out of respect for the process of its formation, without regard for perceived betterment of the lives of its people? Or should the primitive culture be preserved because it is deemed equal to all others, in the eyes of God or by the lights of a humanist ideology?