DNA has been described as a blueprint, or a cookbook, or a code, or a recording. But in fact DNA is a string of molecules. DNA is chemistry. Every molecule does what it must do, according to the laws of chemistry, under the circumstances prevailing at the moment in its immediate environment. The same appears to be true of all other molecules in living organisms. If it can be shown that the outcome of a DNA process, say in reproduction, is analogous to the outcome of something contrived, like a computer code, the fact remains that DNA is chemistry, and nothing more or less. Chemistry is mechanistic, not teleological. No purpose can be found in chemistry.
But if DNA is in fact something contrived, like a computer code, then some intelligence contrived it. A code or a cookbook is designed to yield a certain outcome. Either DNA is a product of Intelligent Design, or it is an outcome of the laws of chemistry. Either God contrived DNA, or God contrived chemistry. Either choice is open to a person with a high view of God.
Yet DNA launches and controls the processes of growth and reproduction, leading us to say for example that she has her father’s smile. Reproduction succeeds when DNA interacts with its host organism in a long, complex process that returns, approximately, to its original state. Then the process begins again. A layman gains the impression that the mechanistic influence of DNA on growth and reproduction is very complex, subtle, surprising, indirect, inefficient, often underestimated, and for the most part still undiscovered and unexplained. But the process is not beyond understanding. Small pieces of it yield, one at a time, to our powers of observation and discovery.
The chemical environment controlling and controlled by DNA is the organism and cell in which it resides. We infer encoded information in DNA by observing its effect on the organism. Without the creature, no scrutiny of the molecule would reveal hidden information. An analogy has been offered: Nothing useful can be extracted from a recording, unless one has a playback device.
It is clear that DNA experiences mutations from time to time, and that these mutations can be inherited. It seems clear that a mutation could have an observable inherited effect on subsequent generations of the organism, though many do not. It seems plausible that the effect of a single mutation could be substantial and beneficial, given the subtle and complex influence of DNA on growth. It seems, from a layman’s casual reading, that such a substantial and beneficial effect of a mutation on succeeding generations has never been observed. It seems that the available mechanistic explanation of the evolutionary process depends heavily on a long series of successful mutations. Success means that the species not only survives and transmits the mutation but that the effect of the mutation confers a survival advantage on subsequent generations of the organism.
This mechanistic model of the evolutionary process seems barely plausible as a hypothesis, and certainly not robust enough to be called a theory. It seems, again to a layman, that some other hypothesis may one day be advanced to better explain the evolutionary facts displayed in the fossil record. Finally, it seems likely that new discoveries will reveal much more about DNA and its influence on its host.
Because it experiences heritable mutations, DNA is a source of information about the biological past. DNA contributes to our understanding of What Happened.
Thursday, May 27, 2038
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
