Thursday, May 24, 2040

Eleven. Observation, practice, innovation and influence.

The constructive activities of people fall into four categories. They are observation, practice, innovation and influence.

Observation has been defined broadly as all means of learning. We observe the world around us and the people in it. We hear and see. We read and measure and explore. We devise clever ways of getting more information than our senses alone can bring us. We take actions and make mistakes and observe the outcomes. We run tests and conduct surveys and observe the results. We look for things that are or are not as we think they should be. We learn from experience, whether sought-after or unwanted.

Observation is a characteristic activity of the scientist, the student, the inspector, the policeman, and the physician. Anyone skilled in an art or craft has been a careful observer.

Practice is associated with repetition. Practice has precedent. The practitioner does the expected thing. In a professional practice, the practitioner does the appropriate thing indicated by the circumstances. The appropriate thing is learned, either from another practitioner as in apprenticeship, or it is learned from one’s own experience. A skilled practitioner, for example a lawyer, may be the only person who knows what he will do under a set of circumstances, but as a practitioner he does know or can determine what his practice requires. Good practice is recognized because it has been shown by experience to produce the desired outcome. Poor practice fails. We speak of shop practice and office practice, for example, to refer to the body of learned actions that produce desired results. Technique is practice.

Innovation, in contrast to practice, produces an unprecedented outcome. An innovation, however trivial, has not previously been seen. Innovation and creativity are similar in this context. Artists innovate. Inventors innovate. Writers innovate at various levels. A written work may or may not be a work of art, but even the most pedestrian writing will contain some innovative elements.

We expect an architect, for example, to be innovative and to create something that conventional practice did not fully anticipate. In contrast, we hardly expect a physician to be innovative in diagnosis and treatment of our illness. Proven practice is considered safer than innovation. Physicians do innovate, we are told, but only with great care.

Innovation in science might be in the design of an experiment or in the formation of a hypothesis. Science is observation and discovery, but discovery often begins with a scientist’s insight and innovation.

Art is produced by innovation plus practice. The artist envisions a new thing, not previously seen or heard or told. The artist’s skill casts the thing into a form called art that captures and reflects the artist’s vision.

The value of art is usually equated to the value that others place on the created artifact. Independently, art has value to the artist, perhaps in proportion to the degree to which his artifact captures his vision.

Engineering is also innovation plus practice, but engineering does not produce art. Engineering produces function. The value of the engineer’s creation is utilitarian. An engineer’s skill is to produce a functional artifact, or more typically to describe the envisioned artifact so that others may produce it.

The spectrum between pure function and pure art is often called design. Designers are innovative. Shopping malls are full of designed artifacts that serve a utilitarian function but are valued primarily for that non-utilitarian quality called style. Style is a form of art.

The fourth category of constructive activity of people is influence. One person influences another with speech or action, with example or authority, with knowledge and logic, with persuasion and negotiation, with sexuality or intimidation, with appeals to mutual interest or mutual relationship.

Influence is one person’s direct engagement of another’s attention. Influence begins with the countenance. The presence, the countenance, the voice and perhaps the touch are central to influence. These elements are central to our customary introduction and handshake. Influence is usually, but not always, deliberate and purposeful.

A work of art or a great book may be called influential, but the direct influence of one person on another is in the personal encounter. Influence leads the other to act, or to listen, or to follow, or to yield, or to agree, or to purchase, or to learn, or to laugh, or to love. Leadership is influence. Teaching is influence. Selling is influence. Personal relationships are influence.

No comments:

Post a Comment