A lion waits in tall grass for the approaching prey. At some moment she will spring and chase. Intuitively we doubt that the lion’s action is instinctive, like a spider’s rushing toward the motion of a trapped fly. We suppose that the lion deliberates much as we would in deciding when to act.
We might suppose that the lion gives chase when she can imagine a successful chase. Informed by experience and the senses, the lion envisions the chase before she springs. We could describe this envisioning with language that describes a human athlete’s performance. The athlete imagines clearing the bar, envisioning the required action in space and time, and then acting. We cannot really know what it is like to be a lion, but it is tempting to believe that the lion, like one of us, is a conscious being with mental apparatus that envisions the action before taking it. Then the lion must have an imagination, however limited. The development of skill requires imagination, just as creativity requires imagination.
If the lion has no imagination whatever, and cannot envision the action before taking it, then she must simply react when some accumulation of stimuli reaches a tipping point. The stimuli might include sight, scent and sound; motion, size, speed, proximity, separation, and so forth. This gives us a quite different and less appealing idea of what it is like to be a lion. Even a worm responds to stimuli. A clever observer might develop an algorithm that predicts what a lion will do in response to such stimuli. The algorithm would be useful in building a robotic lion, but we would doubt that the real lion is like our robot.
There is a middle way, in which the lion learns from experience but still perhaps does not imagine or think about the action before taking it. The lion retains in its subconscious mind an image of conditions preceding every chase, and that image is associated with success or failure in the chase. The lion’s internal “springing algorithm” is created and modified and fine-tuned by all of its experience. Yet this educated lion still springs when immediate stimuli tell it to spring. Imagination and decision may have no role. Conscious thought may have little or no role. And this model would also describe many of the actions of people as well. Like other animals, we learn by association of the outcome with the conditions leading up to the outcome. This is the way we learn about the stinging bee.
The middle way is probably closest to the truth, but still we do not know what it is like to be a lion. The middle way describes the way people behave in many situations, even when they imagine they are being thoughtful and logical.
Sunday, May 20, 2046
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment