Saturday, May 21, 2044

Seven. She knows what she likes.

Why does the female of some avian species prefer the red-feathered male? Biologists answer with a story about chemistry. His red-feathered display produces a response in the retina of the eye of the female that sends chemical signals to her brain, causing her to behave in a receptive way that produces more red-feathered males, and more susceptible females. An engineer might call this a stable feedback loop. Once begun, the cyclic phenomenon tends to reinforce and perpetuate itself. Red reinforces red in the life cycle of the species. Others might call it sexual selection. She knows what she likes.

How did the ability to speak develop in those early stone-chippers with their limited imaginations? We are delightfully free to speculate, because there is so little hard evidence as to why or even when people began to speak. Could it be that the female of the species, or the male, simply liked and responded to the sound of vocalization? Is it not still true that spoken sounds in an intimate or social setting are an attractive or seductive or influential characteristic of a person? Could it be that the variety of sounds once even exceeded the variety of meaningful words? Did speech emerge as art and music before grammatical communication became necessary to survival? Did the anatomy for speech result from sexual selection of those who made music and small talk?

And finally, is preference in the mind of a person, or a community, simply a matter of deterministic chemistry, as it is reported to be in simpler species? In answer to this question, materialists would say yes. Dissenters would say no, there is also an immaterial dimension to the human mind. In other words, there is no accounting for taste. We do not need anything in our genetic code telling us to prefer the red or the blue or the tall and dark or the skillful or the creative. Our individual and community tastes are conditioned by far more than genetics. Yet tastes could still influence genetics through sexual selection.

No comments:

Post a Comment