The description of the human mind has been the province of psychologists and various other observers of human behavior. Recently neuroscience has also contributed to our understanding. The mind resides in the brain. Apparently every turn of mind is associated with some physiological phenomenon in the brain. When a shopper says “I like the red shoes” she is reporting an internal event: some few neurons in some corner of her brain have been treated with some species of neurotransmitter, creating the pleasant sensation of “liking.” Or perhaps her imaginative brain merely anticipates the pleasant sensation that will be hers when she actually acquires the shoes. Or perhaps there is one physiology for liking and another for experiencing.
We readily accept that our emotions are connected somehow with body chemistry. Now we learn that even our merest preference, or distaste, is associated with body chemistry, at least locally within the brain. We can imagine a broad spectrum of emotions from strong to weak, and both positive and negative. Or perhaps our catalogue of emotions is more like a zoo, with creatures large and small, fierce and cuddly. Neuroscience is busily working at its task of describing each one, and where it is located, and what serves to stimulate it. The brain is exceedingly complex, so it seems quite plausible that the great variety of mental states can be matched by a great variety of physiological states.
An engineer knowing little more than this would not presume to describe how the brain works. Instead, the engineer would create a simple model of this most complex structure in the universe, and describe how the model works. A model is a created thing that offers some insight into the real thing. Poets like metaphors; engineers like models.
The brain has different parts serving different functions. One of these will be called Motivation, the heart of our model. Motivation is where we live. Motivation is where much of the interesting chemistry takes place. Motivation is the seat of emotion. It is also the seat of those smaller likes and dislikes that enable us to choose. Motivation might choose to act, or to speak, or to observe, or to think. Motivation is the gatekeeper, moment by moment, controlling these decisions.
We know from experience that the changes we associate with emotion can involve the whole body. A biological description of Motivation would not be confined to some module in the brain. Motivation is often a whole-body experience. But here we are not presuming to know much about biology.
When Motivation decides to act, it calls on Motor, the part of the brain that controls our movements. Another more specialized module controls Speech. When Motivation decides to think, it calls on Reflection.
Reflection is that part of the brain that seems to cast an image on a screen. The image might be like a visual image, or it might be like a piece of music, played in the head, or it might be an English composition under construction, or another person, or a conversation with that person, or thoughts and logic about an abstract concept like justice, or long division carefully projected and worked out on the screen in the mind. Reflection is where we do logic, and Reflection is where we do imagination. We can reflect on true things, like the facts before us. We can reflect on something that is partly imaginary, like a childhood memory. And we can reflect on things both imaginary and fantastic, like an artist’s vision. The big screen of Reflection carries with it a sidebar of logical reflection that tells us, normally, whether the image before us is probably true, or certainly not true.
Reflection, as the name suggests, is akin to imagination. We are able to think because we are able to imagine. Some writers have associated imagination with emotion, but our model does not. Einstein, for example, imagined observers in elevators and on railroad cars, and deduced his theories of relativity from such musings. Imagination is the way we think, whether we are thinking about science or art or relationships. However in the last case we often make decisions without thinking. Or we imagine things to be true that are not true.
Reflection takes time. Motivation, on the other hand, is prompt. It does not take long to stimulate a few neurons. If our shopper needs time to decide whether to buy the red shoes, that is evidence she has sent the question to Reflection. Perhaps she needs to think about money and alternatives and coordinated ensembles and other people’s opinions. In time Reflection returns its product to Motivation, and Motivation decides whether to buy or not to buy.
Some people like to do crossword puzzles. Motivation knows what it likes. Motivation instructs the eyes (through Motor) to read the clue and send it to Reflection. Resources of language and spelling are available to Reflection, but these take some time to access. Eventually Reflection returns the correct word to Motivation, and Motivation gives itself a little chemical high five and instructs Motor to send the hand to write it down.
Other people like jigsaw puzzles. Now Reflection spends its time seeking matches of shape and color. The role of Motivation is similar. Motivation likes the sight and sound of the correct piece fitting into place, and the sense of advance toward the goal. It is a small dose of liking, but it is motivation enough to move on to the next clue or the next piece. A larger reward comes when the puzzle is finished.
But most people do not have time for puzzles. The brain spins the wheel of consciousness (somehow) and we remember the children, the job, the appointment, the homework, the next meal, or our favorite person, or a promise. In a normal person, any of these might produce a chemical response that trumps crossword. Motivation has built a hierarchy in which one thought trumps another, or not. One external influence trumps another. And perhaps one particular person’s influence trumps all other influences. This emotional hierarchy is part of every individual’s unique outlook. Motivation will act accordingly. There is probably no escape in the moment from the dominance of this hierarchy of choice.
But there is hope, because behavior is learned. Today’s outlook and hierarchy are not quite the same as yesterday’s. We can break a bad habit or discover a new insight. People change. If Motivation likes the new insight, the hierarchy is realigned accordingly. Some characteristics of the outlook can be unlearned or realigned, and some probably cannot.
One way to learn is by repetition. Learning to drive would be an example. Motivation wants to learn, and all our powers of observation and reflection are employed in learning. But in time the driver's hands and feet respond correctly to observations of the familiar, without consulting Reflection, and without discernable involvement of body chemistry. Driving has become a habit. Only the unexpected observation will alarm Motivation and affect the driver's heart rate.
When children want to learn, repetition is the way they learn. But occasionally we learn an unwanted lesson. We remember a bad experience. The memory and its associations are linked to the strong negative emotions of the experience. The bad associations are linked to the bad chemistry and remain promptly accessible in Motivation. In time the details of the memory may fade, but some associations remain. These have the power to save, or to cripple.
When a good comedian tells a joke, his audience laughs immediately. The promptness of the response, and the connection with emotion, suggest that humor is a phenomenon that takes place in Motivation. The joke succeeds in part because its subject matter is readily available in Motivation, rather than in the deeper archives of Reflection. Apparently there are two kinds of knowledge, and the comedian’s expertise can identify the kind that is close to the surface and readily available to most of his audience.
Having chosen familiar subject matter, the humorist causes listeners to make a mental connection where there was none before. Students of humor can identify a variety of ways in which the unexpected is introduced and thought to be funny. It is hypothesized that the sudden opening of a new electrochemical pathway leaves secondary chemical effects in its wake that are experienced as humor, making us laugh. If this idea has merit, it is probably not new. In any case it fits nicely with our simple way of thinking about the mind.
Another prompt capability of the mind is facial recognition. We know immediately whether a face in a crowd is familiar, or not. We might need to go to Reflection to retrieve the name, if our acquaintance is not close or recent. And not only do we recognize the face immediately, we also recognize the emotional state of the owner of this face. Our simple model will put facial recognition into Motivation, because our own emotional state can be influenced immediately by a face, even though the mental apparatus for facial recognition is actually located separately from the seat of emotions.
Values, the values that we like to teach our children, are held fast in Motivation. For example, we value justice. A child might recognize injustice, but more generally it requires a mature mind to reflect upon a situation and ask whether justice has been done. Empathy may require imagination, putting oneself in the other’s place. But in any case it is Motivation that likes justice and hates injustice. Similarly, Love is comprehended in Reflection and valued in Motivation. Beauty and Faithfulness are valued in Motivation. Truth may be discerned in Reflection but Truth is valued in Motivation.
God is Love, according to Christian teaching. God is presented in Scripture, not as an intellectual proposition, but as One who makes people the object of his love. We read, for example, that the fruit of God’s Spirit within us is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Whenever these are exhibited, in any person, we suppose neuroscience would look for the sort of neurological activity that occurs in Motivation. In conventional terms, these qualities are said to reside in the heart. Motivation, the seat of emotion and choice and liking and decision, is the heart of a person.
In the New Testament the word love includes behavior that we might call generosity. The story of the Good Samaritan is an example of unfettered generosity that the gospel writer calls love. There are two or three ways by which Motivation might choose to be generous. The first is fear. A small child shares his toys because his mother will yell at him if he does not. Being yelled at engenders negative chemistry in Motivation, which he dislikes. While she is watching, he shares his toys to avoid the bad feeling.
When the child grows up, he might display generous behavior because he likes to be well thought of by his friends and neighbors. His Motivation likes the approval of others, and dislikes their disapproval. His Motivation is strongly influenced, for better or worse, by the opinions of others. Even if this man is also influenced by God’s opinion of his behavior, he is still motivated by the opinions of others. Like the child, he still fears their disapproval, and seeks their approval.
But perfect love casts out fear, in the words of Jesus. Generosity is perfected when Motivation rewards itself for generous behavior, without the necessity of external influence. Again in biblical language this is the fruit of God’s Sprit within the heart, and not external to it. Such generosity is spontaneous, or prompt, as Motivation requires. Motivation does not need to wait for Reflection to weigh the probable response of others to the generous deed. The Good Samaritan acted spontaneously, motivated by compassion.
Many people would agree that the qualities listed above, the fruit of the Spirit, are admirable and to be desired. We could make the list more complete. We might also agree on a list of negative qualities. Then we might agree that the heart is perfected when it is motivated by the positive attributes and averse to the negative ones. A lifetime of study and Reflection might lead to some fine tuning of the lists, as we gain new insights. Many will lose interest in this project as it becomes clear that they themselves are not perfect. Those who persevere will also have to admit that they are not perfect either. But it is not out of reach to say that there is an ideal Motivation that always likes and chooses what is good and rejects what is not good. This ideal behavior is spontaneous rather than calculated. It is from the heart. Christians identify ultimate perfection with the mind of Christ. He alone is perfect. We press on toward the goal.
This discussion of the perfect mind has focused on Motivation, not Reflection. Some people have a great capacity for reflection. Conventional wisdom generally equates this capacity with intelligence. But our behavioral model claims that it is Motivation, not Reflection, which governs the choices we make. Certainly the product of Reflection can have great influence on Motivation, just as certain people and immediate circumstances can influence Motivation. But our actions are not a consequence of what we think, unless we like (or dislike) what we think. We are quite capable of reflecting on a decision, and identifying the better choice, and taking the poorer choice because Motivation likes it. Paul, in the New Testament, refers to this as being a slave to sin. But to be “In Christ” is to be a slave to righteousness, and to take the better choice, having the mind of Christ.
Moral decisions are often emotional decisions. Moral decisions are often made promptly, or spontaneously. Moral decisions are made in Motivation, not in Reflection. Despite centuries of reflection by intellectuals on the logical basis for moral standards, neuroscience debunks the idea that morality is anything but emotional. The Golden Rule appeals to emotion: How would you feel if the tables were turned? Neurologists go on to explain that people without empathy (psychopaths) have no capacity for moral decisions, because they do not know how the other feels. They lack the emotional intelligence that guides morality. Reading Kant will not be helpful. Intellectual arguments for moral standards are usually developed after Motivation has made its choice, not before. Reflection is a servant of Motivation.
If God is Love, then God reveals himself in Motivation and delivers moral guidance from there. God’s commandments resonate immediately. There is no need to reflect at length upon “Thou shalt not murder” and to devise intellectual justification for it. The mind of Christ is attuned to the law of God. The language of the Christian faith is consistent with the recent findings of neuroscience, but not consistent with the dreams of the Enlightenment for rationalization of both truth and morals.
But many people do nevertheless make reasoned arguments in defense of moral standards, and stand by them. Some simply love Reason and will not rest until Reflection has produced a reasoned basis for the moral sense. Many love The Law, and these may feel that the law trumps empathy and the Golden Rule, for example in the case of illegal immigrants. Some in the past constructed a reasoned argument, for example in defense of slavery, which set forth axioms, defended self-interest and trumped empathy. But behavior always comes down to a question of what Motivation values most.
Intellectuals spend time in Reflection and then set forth logical arguments or analyses or explanations pertinent to their field of endeavor. But like the rest of us, intellectuals admit the argument to Motivation because they like it. Intellectuals like sound logic, and they dislike cognitive dissonance. Nevertheless they do not all agree, because each has a different outlook. Intellectuals characterize their differences of opinion in intellectual terms which we need not elaborate. But neuroscience would still insist that each one chooses and promotes what he likes, and rejects what he does not like.
Intellectuals may distrust Motivation, because Motivation makes emotional judgments about what is good, right and true. Despite their best efforts to remain objective, there is hardly a field in which experts do not disagree. On some points they will have agreed to disagree. The disagreement is attributed ultimately to Motivation. One likes this, and another likes that. Intellectuals do their work for the most part in Reflection, but they value it in Motivation.
We will carve out an exception for intellectuals of scientific bent, and for their scientific findings of fact. Science does have the demonstrated capability to discover truth about the material world through observation and reflection. Scientific method has been remarkably effective at reconciling disagreements; especially the hard sciences with their quantitative theories. But questions about what is good, right or beautiful belong to a category of truth that science cannot discover and reconcile.
The young George Washington observed the behavior of older men, and decided which behavior would be his life’s goal. By all accounts he succeeded in becoming a man of honor and integrity, consistent with the eighteenth century standards set before him. We might like to think that George was a man of such strong will and character that he simply rejected and brushed aside the base emotional imperatives that might otherwise have deterred him. But our model insists that Washington’s lifetime decisions were compelled by chemistry within him, and that the strongest biochemistry prevailed. So where did George Washington find the emotional wherewithal that enabled him to succeed at becoming and being an honorable man?
An answer might be found in the last line of the Declaration of Independence. “We pledge to each other…our sacred honor.” Washington and his peers were emotionally invested in the ideal they called honor. Part of the ideal may have been not to display emotion, but the chemistry and the passion were there. George Washington was in love with the idea of honor. A breach of honor would have been appalling. The pledge of honor reveals an affiliation with others who shared the commitment. The pledge is made before God, making it sacred. And the lifelong pledge was made, not least, to the self.
Today the old notion of sacred honor, and death before dishonor, holds little appeal. Other public values, like equality, are ascendant. Similarly, marriage is in decline. The motivation to marry has elements in common with the motivation attributed to Washington in his youth. Marriage is a deliberate decision. Vows are taken before God, and before peers. A successful marriage must be entered and sustained with a passion that trumps all contrary inclinations. This is called faithfulness. Partners are committed to the ideal of a lifelong marriage, as well as to each other. A like-minded community strengthens them. Marriage honors the spouse; marriage honors the children of its union, marriage honors others who hold the institution dear, and marriage honors God, not least because God has chosen marriage as his metaphor for faithfulness. These statements of principle are true to the extent they are passionately held. Without the passion, no one will marry, or no marriage will be successful.
Tuesday, May 29, 2029
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment