Monday, May 17, 2049

Two. People are creative.

People are creative. Some people are more creative than others, but people generally have the ability to produce and introduce new things, tangible or intangible. Creativity is an event originating in the mind of a person. In another context we might like to reserve the word creative for the few who produce art and innovations of enduring value. But here it is observed that creativity is a distinguishing characteristic of people, despite the fact that much created work is not valued and not remembered. Every created thing was first imagined.

One measure of human creativity is the inventory of created things, whether remembered or forgotten, tangible or intangible. For example, every word of every language is a created thing, unless perhaps it is an unmeditated accident. Then follow grammar and idiom and metaphor, and every original conversation and composition and work of literature. A criterion for creativity is that a conscious, cognitive, innovative effort of a person did produce the thing. Imagination and intuition and insight and intent give birth to innovation. The whole catalog of tangible and intangible things thus produced, if we could know it, is immense. Creativity is a cumulative work, in which most people produce only small variations on a theme, and most created things are soon lost and forgotten.

In science, truth is recognized by its quality of not being created in the mind. In art, the opposite is true.  The created thing succeeds when it truly expresses the artist’s vision.

Language, like necessity, stimulates creativity. As soon as primitive people had the grammar to say “Jake is at the lake” and “The moon is in the sky”, someone was bound to say “Jake is in the sky”. Thus language gave rise to the creative genre of the story and the fable and the lie. Humor and hypothesis would soon follow. Language stimulates the imagination. The creative mind attaches meaning to language it receives, whether or not the same meaning was intended by the originator, and whether or not it is true. Understanding the other begins with a creative effort.

Many artifacts are created things, or contain some element of creativity. The first one is created; copies of an artifact are also artifacts but not created artifacts.

A spider’s web and a bird’s nest look like artifacts, but these as we said are not artifacts because they are not made by people. But more fundamentally, are the web and nest and beaver's dam also examples of created things? The answer depends on the role of cognitive processes like imagination and innovation and intent in the minds of such animals.

Biologists assure us that a spider does not intend to build a web. A spider does not have a mind capable of forming intent. A spider is hard-wired, we might say, to perform a certain stepping and spinning choreography in response to external stimuli, and these result in the spider’s web. We may doubt that the spider envisions the web before it is built. But certainly the sight of the finished web could be a stimulus that prompts the spider to move on to other hard-wired behavior. A student of spider behavior might answer these questions.

Does a bird envision a nest before it is built? With due respect to birds, we would like to think it does. Yet it also seems plausible that the bird, like the spider, simply responds to a visual stimulus, a fork of branches, by fetching materials and inserting them round and round until it sees a nest. We might prefer to think that the bird, like one of us, envisions a nest just here and sets about to build it according to plan. To confirm this we would need to know more about the mind of a bird. How long does a bird entertain a thought before acting on it? People require time to envision, to imagine, to form intent, and indeed to think. Does a bird take time? Does a bird think?

Even if a bird does not think, it still does learn. A bird inherits a brain with a space, so to speak, that is fitted to hold a song. Upon hearing the song of its species, the bird retains and imprints that sound in that space. [Or in a new space; we have learned that bird brains grow new neurons to accomodate new notes.] Other spaces will be filled with an imprint of the parent's image, or of the migration route, or perhaps something to do with nest-building.

In any case the bird does not innovate. The plan for the nest that the bird might learn, and might consciously envision, and may even intend to build, is the one characteristic of its species. Different species build different nests, but the innovation that distinguishes them is not spontaneous in the minds of birds. And if the variety of birds’ nests results from some Darwinian process of successful but accidental innovation, or just accidental innovation, this is still not creativity, unless it is also a cognitive creativity in the mind of God.

No comments:

Post a Comment