Wednesday, June 9, 2027

Twenty-four. Endowed by their Creator...

Our founding document declares that all people are endowed by their Creator with rights that include life and liberty. Our Constitution further defines the rights of persons. However, an unborn baby or fetus is not a person under the law.

As a result, our law does not prohibit abortion. The rights of a woman to life and liberty, and her right to privacy, trump the non-existent rights of her unborn fetus. State governments are given the option to declare an interest in life in the womb and to regulate abortion, but only in the late term when the life is viable outside the womb. Such regulation in any case may not infringe on her life or health. No rights are assigned to the unborn life.

A principled objection to this state of the law is the belief that all human life, including unborn life, is endowed by the Creator with a high and irreducible value. In this view abortion should always or nearly always be proscribed. Even the early stages of the embryo are, after all, part of the continuum of human life and ought to be inviolate. In legal terms, the prolife position is that unborn life has a right to life.

This unnuanced view of the value of life will not be enacted into law, because the American electorate will not accept it. Good government is by consent of the governed. The abortion issue has touched many lives, so that most people have some view of it. Many are content to let the law stand as it is. Many would impose greater restrictions or permit different exceptions. Few would prohibit all abortions.

Most would agree that the value of a life in the womb increases as it grows toward the full term. The law has and does recognize this principle, however crudely. Nearly all would take into consideration the health and well-being of the mother. Some would consider the post-natal prospects of the fetal life. These issues are much discussed.

When abortion was generally illegal, the state called upon doctors to enforce the law by denying abortion to patients whose medical circumstances did not meet legal criteria for exemption. The state had no means to make that determination. Medical records, unlike a birth certificate, are not public information.

The law has stepped back in deference to a woman’s right to privacy. If the fetus is not a person, her right prevails under the law. But abortion is not a perfectly private matter, especially in late term. People will know, or imagine they know, that a human life has been taken, and many will be outraged. If the fetus has a face, and begins to present as a person, many of the public will wish to step in and protect it. If a woman’s fetus is healthy and she is capable, the sense of outrage becomes stronger. As the fetus matures, and presents as a baby in the womb, the sense of outrage at abortion becomes stronger yet. It seems unlikely that we will grow accustomed to the abortion license and cease being outraged by what the law permits.

Yet good government is by consent of the people. The law ought not to be changed without the consent of citizens, and particularly women. A good way to obtain that consent under the law is by the process of constitutional amendment.

Suppose political leadership proposes the following amendment to the Constitution:

The protection of law shall not be denied to the unborn.

The statement is deliberately and perhaps usefully vague. It does not declare a fetus to be a person, which would create legal chaos. It does not assign rights to the embryo or fetus as to a person. Yet the proposed amendment reverses current interpretation of the law by declaring that society and the state have an interest in protecting unborn life. Then the state can and must enact laws to defend that interest. The law protects persons and property, and pets and endangered species and quality of life. Now with constitutional mandate the law would be required to protect the unborn.

We learn from women that abortion is a different issue, different from all other issues, and not to be resolved by facile analogy. The duty of government is to ascertain what the people want the role of the law to be on this issue.

If the amendment were to be adopted, it would move the issue forward. Legislatures would fashion laws that soften the outrage. A stronger case would be made against experimentation with embryonic life.

If a large majority of women do not consent to it, the rejected amendment would serve as notice that we are not a society whose laws protect unborn life. Then it can be said clearly that the protection of life in the womb is a moral duty of individuals, not of the law. This may already be the prevailing view of women.

Our present situation is unsatisfactory first because the views and desires of citizens have not been adequately consulted, and secondly because many people make no distinction between legal constraint and moral duty. A change in the law would be unnecessary if every individual recognized the high and irreducible value of human life, and a duty to protect it. Unborn life, and maternal life, and infancy and childhood are all deserving of protection.

No comments:

Post a Comment