Alongside all of this family living and loving and growing,
I worked from time to time on projects. I have described myself as project
oriented. Projects were usually, for me, a solitary activity. A project has a
beginning and an end. A project produces something. My projects might produce
something needed and useful, or something merely interesting, at least to me.
(Incidentally, I have seldom worked on a project that produced what the world
would call art.) In my professional work as an engineer, I often worked on
projects that produced something on paper. I wrote many technical reports. At
home, I might have remodeled the house or landscaped the yard or fixed a
toaster. In retirement my woodshop project might produce a piece of furniture.
In childhood, the goal of my project would typically be to make something that
worked.
I am writing about projects not because my project
descriptions will be particularly interesting to a reader, but because I remember
each one after many years. My father said he remembered everything he ever did,
speaking of his work as an electrician. He wired hundreds of houses. (I helped
him wire a few dozen.) Many were similar but no two were the same. The
differences were in the details, and every detail of his completed project had
to be correct and functional and tight and legal and checked out. If he chose
to run a cable or a circuit by an unusual route for some unusual reason, he
remembered having done so.
When I was quite small I sat on the carpet with my
Tinkertoys and worked at making the thing I saw pictured. I selected the pieces
and counted the holes and put the thing together, or tried to. I preferred to
make a thing that worked, like a crane with a crank and string and hook that
could actually lift something. I’m sure my projects were not always successful,
but I never thought I couldn’t do it. At some point I acquired an electric
motor that was made to fit a Tinkertoy project, but I think I jammed the gears
before long so the motor wouldn’t work. Later I took the motor apart and found
that the electrical heart of it would still run, so I kept and valued that
motor just because it worked. I stepped up to an Erector set, with its nuts and
bolts and motor. My cousin Fred gave me his old Erector set to add to mine, so
I could do the grandest projects like the Ferris Wheel.
Meanwhile, I also had an electric train. My project was to
set it up and see it work. When I was 13, or maybe 14, I had earned some money
and decided to spend it on a bigger and better electric train. My parents let
me know they thought I was too old for such toys, but they relented. I wanted
to set it up and make it work. I wired it so the lights would operate and the
track would switch and the gate would drop as the train approached. I was not
much interested in creating the model village. I liked the moving parts.
I made two or three electric motors during this time. I
looked in some of my father’s books and figured out what the simplest motor
would look like. I made the iron parts from scrap with a hacksaw and file. My
Erector set provided the shaft, and Dad gave me bellwire for the windings. The
commutator and brushes were probably the most difficult design challenge. The
power source for my motor was a pair of big dry cell batteries, or maybe the
transformer from my train set. At some point I made a wheeled vehicle (with the
erector set) which carried the homemade motor and two dry cell batteries, and propelled
itself down the sidewalk.
When I was sixteen I acquired an old car, which of course
needed work. That was the end of lesser projects like trains and motors. After
a series of repair and refurbish projects I had a decent running car. My father
was a ready source of technical advice, and my mother sewed a new headliner
using the old one for a pattern. My father also gave me a job, as an apprentice
electrician, working with him on Saturdays and through the summer, which
provided the income that financed the car projects. In retrospect I would say
that the primary goal of my car refurbishing project was to enable a social
life in high school, which it did. But that’s another story.
Earlier, at the age of eleven, I joined the Boy Scouts. I
made friends and had fun. I also worked on projects, called merit badges. I was
motivated to earn merit badges because the requirements and the end product
were clear, and because I could do some of these by myself. (I had help and advice
from my parents on some of these, but that didn’t make them group projects.) So
I learned the knots; I hiked and swam the distance; I built a campfire and cooked
a meal on it; I played music; I raised pigeons; I planted a garden, and so
forth. Adults and peers approved. I’m sure that was also important to my motivation.
I earned a merit badge for bicycling by riding great
distances with two friends. I recall this adventure as attached to friendship,
not to projects or awards. On three occasions we rode from Compton east to
Knott’s Berry Farm, and west to Redondo Beach, and south to Long Beach. Later I
realized that Mom and Dad made a deliberate decision to let me take risks and
learn about the world, rather than to grow up sheltered and unaware.
At about this time I had a thought, just a passing thought,
which would stay in my memory and point in the direction of many future projects.
We had a shed out back which had been cleaned out. I thought, as boys will do,
that it would be great if this shed could be my private abode. I thought, perhaps
a bit oddly, that if this space were mine I would have charts on the walls. The
charts would depict information like, for example, the weather. I didn’t think
so much about what information would be up there, but the idea of charts and
graphs appealed to me. I must have recently learned what a chart is, and how it
records and conveys information. Later I would spend a considerable portion of
my professional life as an engineer in making charts and graphs; they were
often a product of some technical project I had worked on.
I don’t think of education as a project. The goal of
education is not a diploma or a report card, it is education. Education is too
open-ended to be a project. A term paper
is a project, but aside from these I can’t recall many memorable projects that
I completed in high school or college. I remember the classes and many of the
teachers. I did assigned tasks like tests and homework. I did, and still do
enjoy learning.
An exception would be my Senior Project, memorable and aptly named, in mechanical
engineering at Cal Poly. I chose the topic from a list. I designed and built a
contraption which would demonstrate vibration measurement with electrical resistance
strain gages. The hardware consisted of an electric motor mounted on a
flat cantilever beam with a heavy base. The motor rotated eccentric weights which
caused the beam to vibrate. I used a rheostat to control the motor speed, and
an oscilloscope to display the output. I had a budget from the department to
purchase materials, and I had access to the machine shop to manufacture the
parts. As I recall, I had the results in hand and the report written before I
talked to any professor about it. Later as an engineer I would be responsible (in
part) for just such vibration measurements in operating components of a nuclear
power plant.
I read many books; some in childhood and many after college,
when I had time. To read a book might be viewed as a project, because there is
a beginning and an end. But often there is no salient end product. At best, a
book is educational. To read a good book adds another brick to the
never-finished edifice of one’s education. Non-fiction is educational, and a
good novel is educational as well. We can learn something about people and
places and the flavor of an era that would be difficult to pick up any other
way.
When I started college we were expected to declare a major
immediately, and to take a course or two directly related to that major. I
enrolled in Architectural Engineering, because the building trades were already
familiar to me and to my family. Soon I decided to change to Mechanical
Engineering. That was the right choice.
Upon graduation in 1960 I took a job with General Electric
Company. Their “Atomic Power Equipment Department” was headquartered in San
Jose. My first assignment was located 25 miles away at Vallecitos. I worked for
six months at GETR, the General Electric Test Reactor. My roommates in a San
Jose apartment were all Cal Poly graduates, employed by either GE or IBM as I
recall.
This would be the first of several six-month engineering
training assignments, to be interrupted by two years of military service. At
GETR I would assist with an ongoing project, construction of the AGN test loop.
AGN meant Aerojet General Nuclear; they planned to test fuel for a proposed
nitrogen-cooled reactor. The “AGN loop” in GETR replaced an older “ANP loop”. ANP meant Aircraft Nuclear Propulsion; an idea
that was fading in 1960. I had tasks and duties directly related to the hardware
for the new loop. I learned to work in a nuclear reactor environment, with its
rules and protocols for radiation monitoring. On one occasion I worked briefly
inside the reactor vessel, installing a pipe support bracket of my own design.
I worked with two senior engineers, three of us in a small office at the
reactor site.
In 1961 and 1962 I served in the US Army, having received a
commission through the college ROTC program.
I spent about five months in training at Aberdeen Proving Ground in Maryland,
and the remainder of two years at Pinder Barracks in Germany, in the village of
Zirndorf. As a junior officer in the peacetime Army I had tasks and duties and
responsibilities, but I can’t say I accomplished anything that could be called
a project. I learned something about people and places. I made many friends,
mostly junior officers like myself. We took every opportunity to explore
western Germany, and Western Europe. Shortly after my arrival in Germany,
Khrushchev would order the construction of the Berlin Wall. Before I left,
President Kennedy would deal with the Cuban Missile Crisis. We had those events
to talk about, but we never heard a shot fired in anger, as the old soldiers
liked to remind us. I would be home for Christmas at the end of 1962.
In 1963 I returned to GE and worked a second six-month
engineering training assignment in San Jose. My job was to complete the
development of an experimental device so it could be placed into an operating
reactor, the Vallecitos Boiling Water Reactor. The flux cycler was already
built. A small water turbine spun a train of gears, causing fuel rods to be
alternately shielded from and exposed to neutron flux. One of my tasks was to
find a gear and bearing material that would serve for weeks with no lubrication
but hot water. I read papers on tribology and learned about wear-resistant
alloys. The larger goal was accelerated performance testing of stainless steel
as a fuel cladding material, to see whether stainless steel could serve as an
alternative to zirconium cladding in the core of a nuclear power plant. Stainless
steel cladding in trials was not performing well. My immediate supervisor,
George Reiger, believed that the cause of failure might be low-cycle fatigue,
meaning too much flexing back and forth as a result of heating and cooling. The
flux cycler would test that hypothesis. But meanwhile evidence was showing that
the cause of failure was stress corrosion cracking, not fatigue.
In this assignment I learned two things that would become
part of my stock in trade for the next 35 years. First; George Rieger had a
technical paper authored by Tavernelli and Coffin at GE’s R&D lab, showing
that low cycle fatigue life of materials like stainless steel was correlated
with the number and amplitude of plastic strain excursions imposed by service
conditions. I did calculations of plastic strains in a thin-walled tube,
resulting from external pressure that collapsed the tube onto the cylindrical
fuel pellet. The paper by Tavernelli and Coffin was to be the basis for interpreting
our aborted experiment, but, far more importantly, that paper became the basis
for fatigue design of nuclear power plant components. I suspect the work had
been done some years earlier for the nuclear navy, but that Tavernelli and
Coffin were not permitted to publish until 1962. Their work had already found
its way into design rules for pressure components in naval and commercial nuclear
power plants. The principle was central to much of the work I would do later. And
later I would have the pleasure of meeting and working with Lou Coffin in Schenectady from time to time.
The second portentious lesson from this time was simply the
failure of stainless steel by stress corrosion cracking in the reactor
environment. Many plant components were
manufactured from stainless steel, and some of these (too many!) would
eventually exhibit the same cracking that was being observed in experimental
fuel cladding in 1963. It is an understatement to say that stress corrosion
cracking became a costly problem for the industry. Many people, including me,
would derive a sizable fraction of their income dealing with issues surrounding
intergranular stress corrosion cracking in weld-sensitized Type 304 stainless
steel in the Boiling Water Reactor environment. The technical jargon is so
familiar to me, I can’t say it any other way.
Upon returning to San Jose in 1963 I found an apartment and
lived alone until I found a roommate. In that small apartment I assembled an FM
tuner and a stereo amplifier; an excellent project for me at the time. I
purchased Eico kits and followed the instructions, soldering the joints on the
kitchen table. I also made wooden cabinets for speakers. Those components
served for many years. Eventually the vacuum-tube technology became hopelessly
obsolete and I threw them out.
At GE my next training program assignment, beginning in
August of 1963, was with Dr. Howard Cook. I would design something called an
Observational Test Section, in which water as it boiled could be directly
observed. This water would boil at a temperature of 550 degrees Fahrenheit,
under pressure of 1000 pounds per square inch. Windows of crystal sapphire,
artificially grown, could withstand this pressure and temperature while passing
light or X-rays. Dr. Cook wanted to measure the void fraction; the proportions
of steam and water in the mixture as boiling progressed in a vertical channel.
The configuration of my test section would not be circular, like most pressure
vessels. It was linear and massive. Inside, water flowed past a long, narrow
electric heater.
In October of 1963 I was sitting at a staff meeting in Dr.
Cook’s office. Through the open door I noticed a young woman talking to our
secretary Karen Wright. This was the first time I saw Judy. She had long auburn
hair. After the meeting I asked Karen who she was. I also asked whether Judy
would be coming to the upcoming Halloween office party at a local pizza place.
Karen had the presence of mind to say yes, Judy will be coming with me. So I
met Judy at the Outhouse in San Jose on or before Halloween night, and we
shared a pizza. Judy will report that it was a long time before I called her.
In fact it was November 25, the day of President Kennedy’s funeral. Her name
and number were in the phone book, but it was the wrong number; she had moved.
And she had changed her hair since I first saw her – that may have slowed me
down a little. Eventually I contrived to stroll past her desk and ask for her
phone number. When I finally did call, I was oblivious to the fact that JFK’s
funeral was being broadcast on national television at that moment. I had a tiny
little TV; I seldom watched it for long; and I would certainly not have been
watching TV on the night I intended to call a certain girl. So I did call, and
the rest is history.
I finished my tour of duty with Howard Cook in March of
1964, a few weeks after Judy and I had announced we were engaged to be married.
The drawings for my project had been issued and the parts were being
manufactured. Later I learned that the assembled and operating test section had
blown a gasket. The blowout made a mess, but fortunately no one was hurt. I was
to blame, and I was blamed, but I had moved on. I didn’t even hear about the
incident until two or three years later. It became food for thought: how did I
let this happen? The gasket that failed needed a retainer. In retrospect, I can
see that a sandwich of metal and insulating washers would have sufficed. It was
a design detail that could be left to the end. I did leave it to the end, and
then I failed to take care of it. Several years later, the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission would require a formal and documented design review process for every
nuclear plant component. GE would require such a review across the board; even
for non-nuclear hardware like this. I would have been required by this process
to lay all the drawings on the table and explain all of it to a couple of
senior design engineers. Surely one of us would have noticed that this
non-metallic insulating gasket needed a retainer, and none was provided.
I may have been distracted by events in my personal life.
Judy and I saw a lot of each other in December but went separate ways for
Christmas. At home for a week or so in Downey, I said nothing about having met
this girl, but I was working at divesting myself of all but the future. We
picked it up again and were engaged on Valentine’s Day. Our wedding date would
be July 25.
Judy and her family attended Westminster Presbyterian Church
in San Jose. I had visited Wes Pres and several other churches in San Jose as a
single man, new in town, but I kept a low profile and was not known in any of
them. I attended Westminster Presbyterian with Judy, and the church became a
central part of the environment in which our relationship thrived. In my young
life I had been inside and outside of the church, but when I met Judy, each of
us chose a spouse who was at home in the Christian church.
In March of 1964 I began a third six-month assignment,
reporting to Sam Tagart. The following year I would take a permanent position with
Sam, and our association would continue until and even after he left GE more
than 10 years later. I was assigned projects typical of those I would work on
in the future. I was first introduced to the computer during this period. A
heat transfer program called TIGER had been written some years earlier by Phil
Bray, who was Sam’s boss by 1964. TIGER was capable of calculating temperatures
in fuel and cladding in a boiling water reactor core. It ran on GE’s mainframe
Philco computer, which occupied a large room but was very small by today’s
standards, in terms of capability. In college in the late 1950s my course work
in mechanical engineering never touched on the computer. My roommate was
studying electronics engineering; he talked about Boolean algebra and migration
of plus holes in semiconductors, but I knew nothing about computers until 1964.
For readers who know the difference, TIGER was a finite
difference program. A finite difference program like TIGER would run on a
smallish computer. A few years later we
would have finite element programs for heat transfer and stress analysis, and
suitably larger computer capacity.
Sam Tagart showed me a paper published a few years earlier,
entitled “A Rational Analytic Theory of Fatigue.” He wanted to apply this
innovative method to answer questions in our purview. The paper by Paris, Gomez
and Anderson introduced the Paris Law, as it became known, for predicting the
growth rate of cracks in metallic components. Sam’s instincts were good. During
the next 30 years or more, I would complete many projects related to
applications of the Paris Law, and I would participate with others in many
more. Laboratories were producing data on crack growth rate that would be
interpreted in terms of the Paris Law. We needed to know how a cracked component
would perform in service, and for how long. I applied the method to the end cap
on a fuel rod, in which the closure weld produces a configuration equivalent to
a tight crack.
The Paris Law was an application of fracture mechanics. Paul
Paris was a longtime collaborator of George Irwin, who was considered to be the
father of engineering fracture mechanics. Irwin had worked since the 1940s to
make fracture mechanics a practical engineering tool, applying it first to Navy
ships. I began collecting papers and educating myself, making Irwin’s
engineering fracture mechanics a tool of my trade, and applying it to projects
at GE. Later, in 1967, I attended a short course taught by Irwin at UC Berkeley.
The record shows that I wrote 7 technical reports during
these six months with Sam Tagart. I looked for example at contact stresses in
fuel cladding produced by wire spacers, and the possible effect of these on
long-term integrity of the cladding. I looked at fuel distortion and its
possible effect on clad integrity. A cylindrical ceramic pellet producing
internal heat will take an hourglass shape. The deformation would be small but
predictable. The fuel designer needed assurance that this scalloping effect
would not be detrimental to fuel clad integrity.
I looked at the Vallecitos Superheat Reactor to see what
loads and stresses would result from an earthquake. Much later I would manage a
team of engineers doing seismic and dynamic analysis. This early project was a
beginning.
The last of my six-month training assignments would be with
K. Hikido, looking at fuel cladding design for SEFOR, a sodium-cooled reactor. I calculated temperatures and stresses, but I
don’t remember much more than that because I did not write any reports. I was
performing tasks as instructed, for someone else’s project. The SEFOR reactor
was actually built and operated, successfully serving its experimental purpose.
SEFOR means Southeast Fast Oxide Reactor, located in Arkansas.
GE offered continuing education to engineers during their first
three years of employment following graduation. I began the A-Course in August
of 1963, and the B-Course a year later, in 1964. My B-course classmates were
Dana Ditmore and Jim Strang. These two appear in our wedding pictures; I asked
them to stand up with me along with my brother Sam and my friend Dick Miller.
In 1965 Dana and Jim and I would have begun the C-Course, but GE offered an
attractive alternative: a master’s degree from the University of California at
Berkeley. We would take one semester of graduate courses beginning in the fall
of 1965, to be followed by a master’s thesis.
In March of 1965 I took a permanent position with Sam Tagart
in design analysis. This was interrupted by the hiatus for the semester at UC
Berkeley, to be fully paid incidentally. Sam and his management were very
cooperative. I commuted to Berkeley with my friends Dana and Jim. I took
courses in applied mechanics, and in 1966 I completed my thesis, an application
of fracture mechanics to reactor piping, postulating a crack in the pipe.
The design basis accident for the nuclear power plant
postulated a sudden and complete break of any pipe at any location. There was
some pushback from the industry against the regulator on this. Pipes like these
don’t just break like that. The pipe break was a reasonable basis for sizing
the containment, but were we to design for literally all of the possible
consequences of a brittle fracture, when our materials were not brittle? Yes we
were. The industry lost that argument. As a result we designed the plant to
resist dynamic loads resulting from very hypothetical events. Some of that
became part of my job. One of my design analysis projects was to quantify the
energy-absorbing capability of pipe whip restraints designed by others.
We were beginning to apply finite element methods to stress
analysis of plant components in the late 1960s. A complex shape might defy
analysis, but if is simulated by an assembly of many simple shapes, analysis
becomes feasible. The limiting constraint is availability of computational
horsepower. GE’s mainframe computer was doubling in size and speed every couple
of years, or so it seemed. We also needed a sound mathematical definition of
the small elements that would be assembled to represent large structures. In 1966
I was responsible for trial applications of an element developed at GE’s
aircraft engine division. But in the long run we would use finite elements
developed in academia. I soon had in my desk drawer a finite element program
based on E. L. Wilson’s work at UC Berkeley.
Wilson’s element was two-dimensional, and easy to use. Joe
Rashid, a Berkeley post-doc and Wilson’s associate, had developed a
three-dimensional element that some thought to be too costly, in terms of
computer time, for ordinary use by ordinary engineers like me. But GE hired Joe
Rashid, and I had the good fortune to work with him on an application of his
3-D code. I made the model: a reactor pressure vessel nozzle containing a
crack. Dr. Rashid added lines to the code so that we could get the information
I needed from a succession of runs. He was the overseer of computations,
ensuring that the program ran correctly the first time, every time, and we did
not waste GE’s money on this project. I applied principles of fracture
mechanics to the interpretation of results. I ran several two-dimensional
applications with Wilson’s program to qualify the fracture mechanics
interpretation (called strain energy release rate) for the three-dimensional
application. The project was a great success (in our view). I presented the
results at a conference in Berlin in 1971. I credit Sam Tagart with first
envisioning the project and proposing the collaboration. If my goal was to have
fun working on interesting technical projects, this was certainly a high point
of my professional life.
Judy and I purchased a small house in Los Gatos, moving in
shortly after we were married in 1964. In 1968, when Janet and Julie were
small, I began a project to expand the family room. My father-in-law helped me
on the day we poured concrete, and again when we framed the roof. I did the
rest of the measuring and cutting and nailing myself. My neighbor, an
electrician, looked over the back fence and advised me that I had located the
meter service too far from the corner of the house. I made a joke about having
time to do it over, and I took his advice. I don’t remember all the tasks I must have
done alone, after work and on weekends, but I do remember those interactions
with other people.
By 1974 I was an acting manager, and then a manager, so I
would no longer be doing projects involving finite element analysis; I would
watch others do it. My responsibilities as a supervisor expanded to include
dynamic and seismic analysis. Two of my engineers were conducting in-plant
vibration monitoring of certain reactor internal components. This was required
for first-of-a-kind designs. On one or two occasions the monitoring identified
a design problem. On one or two occasions, operating experience revealed a
vibration problem that we had not thought to monitor. I was deeply involved,
with several others, in resolving these issues. I was involved whenever some
operating plant component cracked or broke. I would typically be the mechanics
specialist on a task force that also included a metallurgist and perhaps a
chemist and a plant systems engineer.
I was also deeply
involved with stress corrosion cracking issues after 1974. A small line in an
operating plant had cracked and leaked. The pessimists expected to see more
cracking incidents, while the optimists looked for reasons to be optimistic. In
the long run, the pessimists were right. When I left GE and went to EPRI in
1980, I would be even more deeply involved with stress corrosion cracking in
operating plants. My broader technical responsibility at EPRI would be
materials performance: how will plant materials perform in service, and how
will we fix the problems?
The business outlook for nuclear power turned down after
1973, and it would never recover. GE’s focus now was to deliver what it had
sold. Line managers like myself were managing production work. Some senior
people left GE to open their own businesses; their expertise had now become
valuable to plant operators. Some left because they had been in love with the
nuclear power dream and were frankly disillusioned or disappointed by the trend
of events. Some left because they missed the excitement of technical innovation
in the early years. I suppose my friend Sam Tagart would be among these. Those
who stayed, and those who would be hired, needed to be project-oriented: Let’s
get this done, and done right. And the work to be done now constituted a number
of large group projects. As a manager I had the sense of working on everything
every day, but my contribution was to advise, to report progress, and to remove
obstacles to progress of whatever sort.
I always saw work extending to the horizon, whether at GE or
later at EPRI. As the computer models were compiled, and the design analyses
were finished, and the reports were issued, events in operating plants gave us
more to do.
In 1975, corporate GE convened a committee in San Jose to
report on the company’s remaining obligations and open issues. I did not see
the Reed Report while I was at GE, but today it can be found online. A 1987
update summarizes the disposition of technical tasks identified in 1975. This
is a good summary of what my GE colleagues were doing in the 1970s. A few of
the tasks were mine.
When Tim was not quite two years old, we began to attend the
Evangelical Free Church of San Jose (now Hillside Church). This was a time when
I was consciously working at assimilating my childhood’s faith and thinking
about what I wanted to teach our children. I listened to teachers and made
acquaintance with individuals who seemed to have gotten it right. Through the remainder
of the 1970s and for many years thereafter I served on committees and held
offices in the church. Meanwhile at the end of 1980 I started a new job with
the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI). I had to leave a men’s Bible
study which met weekly for breakfast across the street from GE. It may have
been those changes which prompted me to undertake a personal project. I worked
on this during lunch hour, when I could take a walk in my new semi-rural neighborhood
near EPRI. My goal was to express something of my faith in 14 lines of iambic
pentameter. The sentiment came from my reflection on the teaching I had been receiving.
I composed these lines:
God grant this in the day Thine heirs
unite
In celebration of Thy perfect love:
If some have known love’s joy but
fleetingly
Complete it then in all who trust in
Thee.
Lead us in hope to look beyond
ourselves
And find among Thy children love’s
delight.
Let each share promise, faithfully
upheld
And binding us together in Thy sight.
Then, self poured out, and thus in
Christ fulfilled.
Love’s finest hour: when old desire is
stilled
And stirred anew for Him by whom we stand,
As serving we are served by thy sure
hand.
Then God shall we know Thee, and see
Thy face
And share alike the fullness of Thy
grace.
JDG 4/81
I liked this
project for some of the reasons that I liked my construction-set projects as a
child. I made it work. I made the pieces fit. I followed the plan. The idea
that I expressed could have been said as well in prose, and certainly it would
bear prosaic discussion, but I had worked out the meter and rhyme and I found
personal satisfaction in that.
I pursued
other writing projects during these years. They were not poetry, so it was more
difficult to know when a project was finished. I composed sentences and
paragraphs while walking, or driving home from work, or lying in bed at night.
When the prose communicated something that I wanted to say, I thought about who
would read it. After I had chosen a reader and sent it off, my mind would turn
to new subjects and sentences.
While at GE
in 1980 I received a phone call from Sam Tagart, who was working at EPRI. Sam
told me of a job opening at EPRI and advised me to apply. I did apply, and I
was invited to interview several people at EPRI, but I didn’t get that job.
However a short time later I was invited back, and I took a different job. I
would be a Project Manager reporting to Robin Jones, and working on stress
corrosion cracking issues. I enjoyed a long association with Robin Jones at
EPRI. I will add parenthetically that the first job was taken by Bob Nickell, very
recently deceased, with whom I also enjoyed a long association.
As a Project
Manager I would not be working on projects. My job was to define a project, to
set goals, to write a task description, to estimate cost, and to persuade
EPRI’s advisors that the money would be well spent if this project accomplished
its stated goals. Then I would assist EPRI’s contract negotiators in
identifying the organization and the people who could complete the project. I
would meet frequently with contractors to review progress and direction. If the
project was successful in the eyes of EPRI and its advisors, I had done my job.
EPRI’s
advisors were engineers and managers from operating nuclear power plants. They
needed to know the condition of their plant so it could be operated safely, now
and far into the future. They needed to anticipate problems and be ready with
solutions. We met quarterly in some American city with our advisory committees,
listened to their plant experience reports, and proposed EPRI projects. On a
second day of meetings we sought final approvals from a higher level committee
of more senior people.
In my
technical area, materials performance, much of the contracted work was done in
research laboratories. The researchers were often scientists, not engineers.
Their goal was not to make the plant operate; it was to observe and measure and
predict the behavior of nuclear plant materials in nuclear environments. The
nuclear environment was high pressure, high temperature water. Impurities in
the water and in the materials were highly prescribed and carefully controlled.
The configuration of materials to be tested and the loads to be applied were also
highly prescribed, to be interpreted in accordance with principles of
engineering fracture mechanics. Crack growth rates were measured remotely by
various clever means. This testing was costly and time-consuming. EPRI funded
some of it. I learned that scientists’ stock in trade was credibility among
their peers and with funding organizations like mine. The best way to know what
scientists really believed was to listen to them talk to each other. Will my
data and my interpretation of it stand the test of time? Among engineers, in
contrast, the key question was “Will this thing work? Will it fly? Will it
serve?”
Scientists
around the world still perform similar testing in support of the world’s
nuclear power plants. Beginning around 1979, they met annually to compare
notes. Their common goal was to produce good, trustworthy, credible data. I
attended several of these meetings during my 18 years at EPRI. Some were in
Europe, some in Japan, and some in the USA. For many years the group was known
as ICCGR, meaning International Cooperative Group on Cyclic Crack Growth. Later
it would be ICG-EAC, where EAC means Environmentally Assisted Cracking. In 2014
the ICG-EAC met in Prague. Some of my younger associates are still
participating. These meetings were not the most important part of my job, but
this experience was among the most memorable. I do value the many professional
associations and friendships I made there. The importance of the work is
attested by the fact that, after 35 years these specialists from all over the
world are still meeting to talk about nuclear plant materials.
As an EPRI
project manager I made many visits to the laboratories where the work was being
performed under contract with EPRI. Most of EPRI’s technical staff were project
managers dealing with their own contractors. EPRI project managers had a high
degree of autonomy. An aggregate of projects was called a program, and I would
eventually be a program manager with supervisory and budget responsibilities,
but the project managers guided their technical work.
I was first hired
in 1980 to work on a program dealing with stress corrosion cracking of BWR
piping. By the early 1990s the disease had spread, as it seemed, to reactor
internals, which were much more difficult and expensive to repair or replace.
BWR owners formed the BWR Vessel and Internals Project (BWRVIP) and asked EPRI
to manage it. I proposed a task plan and a budget, and got the new project off
the ground. In the long term the BWRVIP was managed by my friend Warren
Bilanin, whose skills and temperament were better suited to the task. I was
still basically a technical guy who had learned some management skills, but
Warren was willing and able to spend all day on the phone with customers or in
meetings with minions. I was not.
On the
subject of self-analysis, I recall what a supervisor wrote about me back in
1977 at GE: “He tends to be more demanding of himself than his people.” I
remembered this because it is true. I worked without being prodded, and I was
unwilling to prod a subordinate. Much later, shortly before I retired, my
supervisor was prodding me to fire a certain underperforming individual. He
explained that if he did not push me to fire this person “you will take the
pain”. That was also an accurate observation. I would work overtime to make my
subordinates look good. Some of them knew and appreciated the fact.
I had a
friend at EPRI who occasionally stopped by to chat. Mel Lapides usually
introduced himself when he walked into my office by saying “it’s interesting
---” and then he would lay out some technical conundrum, or some observation
about the way people are or the way the world is wired, and he would often draw
some diagram on the board that communicated a universal truth. He made
reference to his book, which I gathered would contain many such observations. Mel
also mentioned that he had been a writer for Lenny Bruce, and he did have the
wit for it. I felt honored by the fact that my visitor was undoubtedly the
smartest person in the building (though perhaps not the most productive) and I
remember his reference to me on one occasion as the guy who questions
everything. We talked about my projects, and his, and other people’s, always
being ready to question the conventional wisdom in the industry.
I was
employed in the nuclear power project for nearly 40 years. In retrospect an
engineer like myself can say yes, the nuclear power plant works. In 2015 there
are 100 water reactors operating in the US, and they have performed very well,
especially in recent decades. 35 of these 100 were designed by GE. But success
came at a price. Deficiencies in design or materials were identified and
remedied; these kept me busy. Operators learned to operate, and regulators
learned to regulate, as a result of errors along the way. The Three Mile Island
accident was a case in point. More recently some plants have been closed
following botched repairs. Some have closed because lower cost power became
available in the region. Nuclear power plants, when operated safely and
efficiently, are labor intensive, and the necessary staff does not come cheap.
At Three
Mile Island in 1979 the reactor destroyed itself before it was brought under
control. The public was not harmed by radiation release but some were harmed by
the disruption of evacuation. These outcomes are unacceptable to owners and
neighbors of the plant. It is good but it is not enough to say that the public
was protected from the radiation hazard.
More
recently in Japan an accident destroyed a nuclear power plant. Radiation was
released and again the public was harmed by the evacuation disruption, if not
by the radiation. Contamination of the surrounding land was extensive. The
cause of the accident was high water that flooded and damaged the emergency
power supply. No operating plant can shut down safely without some source of
power.
The cause of
the high water was a large tsunami. The plant was designed to withstand a
smallish tsunami, but not a large one. Why did engineers choose the smaller
number as the design basis, when it was known to some, even then, that much
larger tsunamis had occurred near that site? And why did Japanese regulators accept the
smaller number? We have no satisfactory answers, but we have more questions.
The design deficiency was recognized in later years, but institutional Japan
was unwilling to act. This unwillingness is a subject of the Japanese accident
investigation report, published in 2012. The report offers an interesting
analysis of Japanese culture. The lesson we should take from the Japanese
experience is to ask how American culture, which is very different, could lead to
such blatant disregard of apparent risks. As for Japan, I speculate that to
adopt a realistic design basis for the tsunami would have meant recognizing
that this coastal site is unsuitable for a nuclear power plant. The required
high sea wall would have been impractical. That would have been acutely
embarrassing in Japan, because the site had already been chosen.
I am
reminded of a conversation I heard at EPRI about the merits of the Japanese approach
to regulation of nuclear power. The Japanese authority mandated a lengthy
annual outage for every plant. The implicit charge to the operator was to
(please) conduct maintenance and inspection activities as necessary during this
outage to ensure safe plant operation, and do not embarrass Japan. The US
regulatory approach, in contrast, was to make rules and enforce compliance. I
believe the US regulator would have asked to see the history of high water
along that coast. The Japanese regulator left such technical details to others.
Unfortunately, no amount of inspection and maintenance of the operating plant
could mitigate the tsunami risk.
But this was
a GE-designed plant. It is fair to ask what GE might have done to mitigate the
severe consequences of this accident. I have tried to imagine a GE engineer
questioning the tsunami design basis, but success seems unlikely. GE did not
have the responsibility or the site-specific historical data. Another set of
arguments says that a GE plant of later design would have fared better during
the accident, and that is probably true. Finally it is claimed that different
actions by a better-informed operator during and after the accident would have
reduced the extent of damage. That was also true of the TMI accident.
Around 1973
I became aware of organized opposition to nuclear power from those who deemed
it too dangerous or dirty or difficult to deploy safely. Defenders responded at
first by pointing to other activities that were clearly more dangerous and
dirty, yet accepted by the American public. The use of coal and the use of agricultural
pesticides are two activities that come to mind. But critics made it clear that
they did not like these other activities either. This was the beginning of the
environmental protection movement. Critics also responded with outrage: How
dare you bring this new and risky thing into our community without our
permission? The ‘outrage factor’ that I heard about in the 1970s led eventually
to a shift of power. It seems unlikely today that a new nuclear power site
could be opened, because local opposition and due process could and would
prevent it. The nuclear waste disposal site in Nevada at Yucca Mountain has not
been opened for just this reason. Local opposition has trumped federal control
of federal land.
Conventional
wisdom in the industry held that nuclear power will be deployed if and when
people believe it is needed, but not before. Purveyors of nuclear power in the
1970s showed that our standard of living is directly related to consumption of
energy. Today our consumption of energy is declining, and our standard of
living is also declining, yet the public is unmoved. Apparently other factors
trump the standard-of-living argument.
I was at
EPRI when global warming became a public issue. In this arena nuclear power has
merit. Energy is produced without the release of greenhouse gasses. But nuclear
power advocates at EPRI chose not to press this point because deployment of
nuclear power would not be enough to reverse the trend. I heard our director at
EPRI say that we ought not to oversell nuclear power as our predecessors did in
the 1950s, when someone said it would be too cheap to meter. Today my
observation is that nothing we can do will be enough to reverse the increase
and produce a reduction in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Those who are
alarmed by scientific forecasts do not have the geopolitical power to enforce the
necessary reduction. The list of actions that must be taken is formidable, and
the world is not acting. (Widespread deployment of nuclear power is only one
item on the list.) If I am correct there are two possible long-term outcomes.
We might learn that carbon dioxide is not, after all, the key to global climate
control, and that climate is not changing in the long run as we had feared. Or,
climate change will happen and people will adapt to it, as they have in the
past, not without difficulty, but successfully.
Many people
believe that science has foreclosed the first possible outcome: we already know
that by reducing carbon dioxide emissions we can prevent climate change. But I
believe that very few knowledgeable scientists will stand before their
colleagues and make this claim. I think many will say that man-made emissions
influence climate. Many will say that reduction of emissions is advisable in
light of current knowledge. But climate science does not prescribe a solution
to climate change. Climate science does not even address the social, political,
economic and engineering aspects of CO2 reduction on a global scale.
Science describes the problem, but it is a mistake to think that science has
the solution. Science is discovery; it is not problem-solving.
In any case
I doubt that the USA will return to nuclear power in the foreseeable future.
Our postindustrial society favors technology with a small footprint. Nuclear
power belongs to a bygone era of heavy industry and large capital investment
and big construction projects. Today we can hardly maintain yesterday’s
infrastructure. Young Americans dream of a life off the grid, in which
everything is handheld or roof mounted or locally grown. But elsewhere on the
globe, nuclear power might well be part of another people’s dream of progress
out of want and toward prosperity.
I retired
from EPRI in 1998. Judy and I relocated to Belchertown in western Massachusetts
and purchased a new home. This was our third home, and for the third time we
completed several decorating and landscaping projects. During our first year or
two in Belchertown I built a gazebo in the back yard.
I had built
a gazebo in San Jose about ten years earlier, so I had time to think about a better
way to do it. Instead of conventional rafters and joists I decided on a
three-tier roof supported on 8-sided rings. The lower ring would be in tension
so it would be assembled with through-bolts. I chose angles and proportions for
the roof, and then calculated every length and angle for the framing members,
which were all 4x4s. Then I cut and assembled the pieces. Joists were
unnecessary, so the ceiling is an open dome. The foundation is a trench filled
with large loose rocks, of which we had many on our lot. I had read someplace
that a foundation of loose rock does not need to be as deep as the frost line,
if it is well drained, so I contrived a rock-filled drainage ditch. I rank the
gazebo my favorite construction project.
In
retirement I have acquired tools and made furniture in a basement workshop. I
have made quite a few pieces of furniture, and each one was a project. But I also
attach value to the experience of learning woodworking. The development of
skill is an education; it is never finished. I acquired tools and learned to
use them. I read books and followed forums. I tried different techniques and
found those that suited me. I learned how much I didn’t know, and became aware
of the gap between my skills and those of a lifetime pro. I learned to
recognize the work of a few of those pros by their signature designs and design
cues.
Woodworking
reminded me of lessons I had learned from my father. To finish a project, start
soon, and stay with it until it is done. It will take time, but it won’t take
forever. Cutting and fitting dovetail joints, for example, takes time. Go down
to the basement and put on some music and get started, and stay until it’s
done.
A more
idiosyncratic project was completed in an afternoon several years ago. Every object
and location and phenomenon in the cosmos has its characteristic temperature.
The internet makes it possible to gather such information. I found that the
coldest place in the cosmos is thought to be the Boomerang Nebula, which is
about one degree above absolute zero. The hottest place is the hottest star
interior, thought to have a temperature of several hundreds of millions of
degrees Kelvin. Between these extremes I collected about 30 more interesting
observations about temperatures of stars, flames, lava, light bulbs, etc, and
placed them on a handsome chart. This is the sort of chart that would have
appealed to me when I was 12 years old, if someone had been available to
explain the logarithmic scale of temperature. Last year I discussed this chart
with a small class of high school physics students. They found the information
interesting, more or less. Some doubted that a candle flame could be hotter
than molten lava, so we had a useful discussion about that. But I sensed that
none of them understood the motive which compelled me to create this chart as a
retirement project.
A similar
motive, whatever it was, led me into a more ambitious project. Every place on
earth, at every latitude and every season of the year, has its characteristic
length of day and length of night. Every latitude and season has its length of morning
and evening twilight, during which the sun is not far below the horizon. We can
describe twilight periods as either civil twilight, in which one can still read
a book outdoors, or nautical twilight, in which the horizon is just visible
from a ship at sea. I presented all this information graphically in a few
charts on a single board. Many people in every age, especially mariners, even
centuries ago, would have understood what the charts depict. The computer and
the internet made it possible for me to calculate the numbers on daylight,
twilight and darkness and to draw the charts. Others may have done something
like this but I could not find their presentations on the internet, so I made
my own.
Another
graphical presentation project exists only in my imagination. I shall describe
it here so that some like-minded investigator can make it a science project. It
is a graph of descending velocity versus size. I have in mind the velocity of
objects descending toward the earth under the influence of gravity. The slowest
velocities are at the top of the graph. These might be the settling rate of
fine dust in the atmosphere, or the sinking rate of tiny diatoms in the sea; perhaps
some fraction of one meter per day. And these are among the smallest objects
which fall. Smaller objects will be held in suspension by Brownian motion; they
will not descend; they will form a colloidal suspension. So these small-and-slow
phenomena are displayed near the upper left hand corner of the graph. Then near
the opposite corner of the graph are the largest objects falling at the highest
velocity imaginable. An asteroid originating in the solar system and travelling
directly toward the earth would enter the atmosphere at a velocity as high as
72 thousand meters per second. The atmosphere will slow it down, but if the
asteroid is very large the atmosphere will not slow it much. These
large-and-fast phenomena are displayed near the lower right hand corner of the
graph. Everything else will display somewhere near the diagonal line between
these corners.
Clearly we
will need logarithmic scales to display the very wide range of sizes and
velocities. We will do some research to discover the falling velocities of
raindrops and snowflakes and hailstones in the atmosphere. We will discover
that large raindrops break up into smaller drops, so that raindrops cannot be
as large or fall as fast as hailstones. Stones fall faster than hail, and lead
shot falls faster than stone, for spheres of the same size. Different classes
of objects will fall on different parallel lines on this graph. We will need to
compute terminal velocities, if someone hasn’t done it for us, which is the
reason this project won’t be easy to complete.
If an object
is not a sphere we can still assign it a size for our purposes. The size of an
arrow, for example, might be characterized by the size of the imaginary hole it
makes in the atmosphere as it falls. The arrowhead and the feathers determine
the size. I read someplace that the Titanic struck the ocean floor at a
velocity of 35 knots. The size of the hull might be characterized by the beam,
or by the average of beam and height. Because we are displaying size on a
logarithmic scale, it won’t matter much. We can put the Titanic on the chart of
descending velocity versus size. We can also put a baseball and a skydiver and
a peregrine falcon on this chart.
Why would
anyone like to do this? For the same reason that I would like to do it.
Judy is a
photographer. She brings her camera and waits for the shot, or she persuades
people to line up for the group photo. I am not good at those things. But I did
complete a photography project back in the 1980s. I had a pretty good film
camera. I built a stand for it, bought a close-up attachment, and copied many
of the old family photos that I found in borrowed albums and frames. When the internet became available I followed
some genealogy forums, made some personal contacts, and acquired some old photos
that we had not seen and some family history that we did not know. More recently
I have scanned the copies of photos and collected them on my hard drive.
Mother
wanted to preserve the story of her family in Texas, before they came to
California in 1919. In the late 1980s I gathered up what she had and wrote a
few paragraphs on the Nuckols, Hill, Bishop and Friou families. That writing
project needs to be updated, because more information about the old days has
become available as a result of the internet, and some of what we thought we
knew is not quite accurate.
Later I
wrote a history of our Gilman family, and another of the Douglass family of
Randolph County Illinois. Both of these are about times that are out of living
memory. The challenge for me is to find all the relevant information that can
be found and to weave it into a story. The project is finished when there is
nothing more to be found. I am aware of a few bits of information in my files
that need to be added, so these projects are never quite finished. And family
members, including me, occasionally remember another story they heard years ago.
The
histories of families we know emerge from a larger context in American history.
Why did these individuals choose to move from location A to location B during
these years? Often the answers can be gleaned from history books. They were
part of a larger movement, and other families shared the same history. Invariably,
in our accounts of family history in the 19th century, location B
was west of location A. Here is another measure of a writing project on family
history: it is complete when it connects with larger history.
A year ago I
was teaching physics to high school students. Teaching is decidedly not a
project; it is a stand-up performance. Even a physics teacher needs to be in
the moment, as they say, when talking to teenagers. I enjoyed teaching six
relatively cooperative students at Community Christian School; I might not have
enjoyed teaching a large class in a public school. But in either case I could
not have done this when I was a young man. It required a lifetime for me to
become sufficiently spontaneous and articulate, even when my subject was as
comfortable and familiar as physics. Teaching physics was surely one of the
best things I have done in retirement. I enjoyed dusting off and talking about
some of my old projects, like the homemade electric motor, and a crystal set
from Boy Scout days. I talked about how things work, and I learned how to
explain some less familiar things like the elementary
principles that produce the Aurora Borealis.
In 2003 I
had for some reason a few lines of text in my head, so I decided to write these
down. One idea led to another, and I composed a series of essays during the
next few years. These may be found here.
Also on this
site are a few sermons that I wrote out before I delivered them on a Sunday
morning at our little church. I did not preach a sermon anywhere until I was
nearly 70 years of age. Like teaching high school, I was not up to it when I
was younger.
The writing
project I began in 2003 might be finished; I can’t be sure. Maybe the essay muse
will visit me again. This current writing project is much different. It
required only a few weeks from start to finish.
Joe Douglass
Gilman Jr.
February 2015

No comments:
Post a Comment