Friday, May 22, 2043

Eight. Outlook, again.

Every person has a different outlook. There is much discussion of the factors in nature and nurture that combine to make each of us unique. And if many people seem to be alike in certain respects, it is often discovered that those similarities are cultural rather than universal among people.

We have little difficulty in distinguishing one person we know (unless a twin) from six billion others. But we do perceive that people everywhere have some universal characteristics, which we commonly refer to as human nature. For example, people everywhere tend to be self-centered. Sociologists might describe concentric circles, with myself at the center, followed by my children, my spouse, my kin, my friend, my tribe, and so forth, and with nearness to the center being a measure of caring or concern or empathy or love.

Conversely, great distance from the center can be envisioned as a measure of enmity, or hostility, or disregard, or hatred, or xenophobia. The people at greatest distance from those near our center are those whom we demonize. The word implies a willingness, or even a duty, to kill or destroy or defeat people viewed as evil, or as a threat to life itself.

Extreme views like this can be recognized and rejected by thoughtful people, but the capacity to demonize other people seems to be a part of human nature. Certainly it is part of our history and part of the outlook of many people on earth today. Belligerence is a part of human heritage.

The Christian ethic calls for a deliberate rejection of those circles of hatred and self-centeredness. Christians and perhaps others are called upon to love their enemies; to resist not evil; and to regard the other as more important than the self. We are commanded to oppose the primal imperative called human nature. A reason is given: If we are children of God, we may not draw circles to exclude those whom God has not excluded.

Friday, May 23, 2042

Nine. Language and imagination.

Some thousands of generations ago, language and imagination seem to have crossed a threshold somewhere in a local community of stone-chippers, and a few of them passed from a period of stability to a period of instability. We began to think and speak and imagine in ways formerly unknown. This capability once initiated would quickly reinforce itself and grow stronger.

Language and imagination enabled the creation of new categories in the circles of our outlook. The language and symbols and artifacts and habitats and practices of others became different from our own, and those who were different we distrusted and pushed away. Belligerent tendencies were amplified by new criteria for identification of friend and foe.

Language and imagination enabled us to envision and talk about and think about the reality out of sight, beyond the horizon or over the ridge. We thought about the alien tribe who lived there. We imagined, often correctly, that they demonized us, because we demonized them. We imagined, again correctly, that they might act to allay their fears by attacking us. If our more primitive and unimaginative ancestors had their motives to attack another clan or species, we now had new motives and new enemies among our own kind.

Language and imagination were great assets in warfare, and particularly in leadership. Our leader could articulate our fears and focus our response. Our leader could know his less imaginative enemy and anticipate his actions. Our leader could make plans and communicate them to his warriors. Our leader could think and speak on his feet. Our evil but slow-witted enemy would be defeated and destroyed. Our stone-chipping opponents have weapons, but we have strategies as well. The surviving tribe was the tribe able to produce leaders and followers more proficient in the use of language and imagination.

This kind of thinking about the past, this exercise in imagination and language, can serve to explain how people got to be so smart so fast, before we left the cradle of our origin, and incidentally before the advent of race. It might explain why people have been and still are so quick to identify friend and foe, ourselves and the others, sometimes with deadly intent, and other times with merely competitive attitude, using a wide variety of cultural cues. Xenophobia and belligerence were not the sin of Adam, but perhaps they were the sin of Cain.

Thursday, May 23, 2041

Ten. What is truth?

Speculation on the past, a narrative about What Happened, if offered by a serious student of the past is called a hypothesis. Some people may receive a particular hypothesis as plausible, and others will reject it as implausible or impossible. (A larger third group will be disinterested). An individual receives a hypothesis if it fits into the established framework of his outlook. He receives it particularly well if it tends to strengthen and expand that framework. And people are likely to reject a hypothesis that does not fit. We express these reactions informally by saying I believe that could be true, or I believe that is not true. From statements like these we learn something about another person’s outlook. Notably we do not learn whether the hypothesis is true.

Scientific discipline approaches a hypothesis more formally. Scientists communicate with each other. If all observations support a hypothesis, and if those observations are each verifiable, and if observations could refute the hypothesis but do not, then the scientific community might agree to elevate the hypothesis to the status of a theory. The hypothesis lives in probationary status until it is discarded when observations refute it, or until there are confirming observations judged sufficient to qualify the hypothesis for promotion to the higher status called theory.

In biology, hypothesis and theory seem to be narratives about What Happened, in the past and up to the present moment, whether in a time scale of growth and metabolism and reproduction, or in the much longer time scale of evolution. Events occur coarsely in populations of organisms, or in the structure and function of organs and organisms, or in the fine details of molecules and mutations. Biologists might make predictions, but predictive theories in biology are not fundamental. Prior cause and effect are fundamental. Truth-seekers in biology look for complete and accurate narratives of past events, up to and including a complete description of the current generation. Historians and cosmologists share this perspective on the characteristic quality of truth: It really did happen.

In contrast, physics and chemistry tout predictive theories. The observable principles of chemistry are thought to derive from the more fundamental laws of physics. The laws of physics are thought to be imperfectly known, yet they are reliable in their current form as predictive theories. Truth-seekers in physics look for the more complete and more elegant statement of principles governing the behavior of all matter everywhere, past, present and future. This is arguably a different category of truth than the true narrative of events.

The laws of physics are discovered by careful observation of the behavior of the matter they describe. One might expect that laws thus derived would be merely empirical. But historically some of the great discoveries of physics have displayed that quality called elegance that almost compels a higher estimate of their origin. Discovery of the laws of physics can be compared, somewhat poetically, to the discovery of rare jewels in the bowels of the earth, or in Newton’s metaphor, among the stones on the seashore. The jewel-like quality of elegance perceived by physicists is in the purity and generality of the mathematical expression of the laws they discover. Where this elegance is lacking, physicists perceive that their work is not finished.

Physicists do not claim, or at least not unanimously, that the laws of physics exist independently of the matter they describe. Newton’s elegantly stated laws and their elegant refinements came into existence when and where time and space and matter, or something more fundamental, came into existence. To claim otherwise would seem to assign the origin of the laws of physics to the mind of God, which is currently unfashionable. But physicists do claim that the laws of physics are discovered, not invented, by people. The laws of physics were a reality from the beginning in the expanding universe. And if the laws are supposed to be mutable, the reality they describe was also mutable.

Observations in physics have outpaced elegant interpretations. The fine tuning of the universe, as certain coincidences are described, appears to be inelegant, improbable, empirical and contrived. Moreover, the cosmos at very large scale is not behaving as current theory would predict. Physicists seek more complete, more elegant, more fundamental, self-confirming mathematical interpretations of observations. The search for beauty continues in the deep mine of string theory.

The ancient Greeks investigated vibrating strings, and discovered surprising relationships between number and harmony. Simple integer ratios in the lengths of strings produced the sounds most pleasing to the ear. Integer ratios also emerged as fundamental in their studies of geometry. The relationships between observation and theory and number had that quality of beauty or elegance which was associated then and now with the discovery of truth.

Medieval astronomers were motivated to find meaningful numbers and ratios in the orbits of planets. A discovery of pure and simple integer ratios would be evidence of harmony in the design of the heavens – the music of the spheres. Harmony, simplicity, beauty and elegance would be evidence of truth. Reason rejects the alternative; that such a discovery could be a meaningless coincidence.

Astronomers did not find the harmony they had sought. Instead, Kepler and Newton discovered that the orbit of planets is an ellipse, and that the ellipse derives from the law of gravity. The truth proved to be in a way simpler and certainly more elegant than the ancients had supposed.

Modern physicists have a similar motivation. Hope is invested in a string so small as to be imaginary. Yet the harmonious characteristics of a particular string, even an imaginary one, can be derived mathematically. If the numbers associated with the vibration of the string are precisely similar to numbers associated with the observed fine tuning of matter in the cosmos, the mathematical statement about the string will be an undeniably elegant, and therefore a presumably true statement of the laws of physics. The imaginary string need not be a reality, but the mathematical statement that describes the string must also describe observable reality in precise analogy.

String theory is faltering, and may prove to be as unsuccessful as were alchemy and the search for the music of the spheres. If the pattern of the past is repeated, string theory will be swept aside by a new, brilliant, elegant insight of an imaginative person who studies observations.

If the laws of physics are a second category of truth, after the true narrative of events, pure mathematics would seem to be a third category. We do not claim that mathematical truth, two plus two equals four, is conditional upon anything whatsoever. If the laws of physics are tied to a physical universe, mathematical principles are not. In mathematics, truth exists apart from matter.

More on truth

Thursday, May 24, 2040

Eleven. Observation, practice, innovation and influence.

The constructive activities of people fall into four categories. They are observation, practice, innovation and influence.

Observation has been defined broadly as all means of learning. We observe the world around us and the people in it. We hear and see. We read and measure and explore. We devise clever ways of getting more information than our senses alone can bring us. We take actions and make mistakes and observe the outcomes. We run tests and conduct surveys and observe the results. We look for things that are or are not as we think they should be. We learn from experience, whether sought-after or unwanted.

Observation is a characteristic activity of the scientist, the student, the inspector, the policeman, and the physician. Anyone skilled in an art or craft has been a careful observer.

Practice is associated with repetition. Practice has precedent. The practitioner does the expected thing. In a professional practice, the practitioner does the appropriate thing indicated by the circumstances. The appropriate thing is learned, either from another practitioner as in apprenticeship, or it is learned from one’s own experience. A skilled practitioner, for example a lawyer, may be the only person who knows what he will do under a set of circumstances, but as a practitioner he does know or can determine what his practice requires. Good practice is recognized because it has been shown by experience to produce the desired outcome. Poor practice fails. We speak of shop practice and office practice, for example, to refer to the body of learned actions that produce desired results. Technique is practice.

Innovation, in contrast to practice, produces an unprecedented outcome. An innovation, however trivial, has not previously been seen. Innovation and creativity are similar in this context. Artists innovate. Inventors innovate. Writers innovate at various levels. A written work may or may not be a work of art, but even the most pedestrian writing will contain some innovative elements.

We expect an architect, for example, to be innovative and to create something that conventional practice did not fully anticipate. In contrast, we hardly expect a physician to be innovative in diagnosis and treatment of our illness. Proven practice is considered safer than innovation. Physicians do innovate, we are told, but only with great care.

Innovation in science might be in the design of an experiment or in the formation of a hypothesis. Science is observation and discovery, but discovery often begins with a scientist’s insight and innovation.

Art is produced by innovation plus practice. The artist envisions a new thing, not previously seen or heard or told. The artist’s skill casts the thing into a form called art that captures and reflects the artist’s vision.

The value of art is usually equated to the value that others place on the created artifact. Independently, art has value to the artist, perhaps in proportion to the degree to which his artifact captures his vision.

Engineering is also innovation plus practice, but engineering does not produce art. Engineering produces function. The value of the engineer’s creation is utilitarian. An engineer’s skill is to produce a functional artifact, or more typically to describe the envisioned artifact so that others may produce it.

The spectrum between pure function and pure art is often called design. Designers are innovative. Shopping malls are full of designed artifacts that serve a utilitarian function but are valued primarily for that non-utilitarian quality called style. Style is a form of art.

The fourth category of constructive activity of people is influence. One person influences another with speech or action, with example or authority, with knowledge and logic, with persuasion and negotiation, with sexuality or intimidation, with appeals to mutual interest or mutual relationship.

Influence is one person’s direct engagement of another’s attention. Influence begins with the countenance. The presence, the countenance, the voice and perhaps the touch are central to influence. These elements are central to our customary introduction and handshake. Influence is usually, but not always, deliberate and purposeful.

A work of art or a great book may be called influential, but the direct influence of one person on another is in the personal encounter. Influence leads the other to act, or to listen, or to follow, or to yield, or to agree, or to purchase, or to learn, or to laugh, or to love. Leadership is influence. Teaching is influence. Selling is influence. Personal relationships are influence.

Tuesday, May 24, 2039

Twelve. Some people believe...

Some people believe in God, and some do not. God is reality in the experience and outlook of some, but not others. This observation is consistent with the teaching that God reveals Himself to whom He will.

Some say that God reveals Himself in nature, or in Holy Scripture, or in the teaching and sacraments of the Church, or in the faces of children, or in loving relationships, or in music, or in meditation. Yet others who enjoy or investigate these things do not necessarily report they have discovered God. God reveals Himself to whom He will, by means of His choosing. People who hold this view may pray that God will reveal Himself to a particular person.

An alternative view would say that God tries, yet often fails to reveal Himself to every person by various means. This view grants more autonomy to people, and less to God. A view that diminishes God is rejected by a theology that elevates God without reservation.

God’s creation, the cosmos, or the universe, moves through space and time from the beginning to the present, and on, presumably, to the end. More accurately, space and time are among the physical characteristics of the cosmos God creates. Life appears long after the beginning, and people appear shortly before the present. God is not located in the cosmos, nor is he outside of it, if an outside can be imagined. Our revealed God is not an observable item in the cosmos, in space and time. God is not verifiable or falsifiable through observation. Science does not discover God. This absence of observation is consistent with the teaching that God is Spirit. God is the Creator of physical reality, with its life and space and time.

The world of nature is the world of the physical, the tangible, the observable. Intangible realities such as God, and truth, and justice, and love, have been called spiritual realities. People may regard the human mind, or the better part of it, as a spiritual reality, and thus consider themselves to be spiritual people. Spiritual reality is discerned by observing people, not by observing nature.

But God is not an item in either this spiritual world of people or in the natural world. Rather, according to the people to whom God has revealed himself, it is God who creates and is sovereign over all reality, both the spiritual and the physical. This observation of and by people is consistent with the ancient teaching that God created the heavens and the earth; the higher things and the mundane realities. We live and have our being, both natural and spiritual, in God.

Justice, for example, is real in the perception of people because it is real in the mind of God. But justice is not a tangible, physical thing. Science does not discover justice.

God reveals Himself, yet not without effort and response on our part. Revelation is a gift of God; the thirst for God and for His revelation is a gift; the ears that can hear and the mind that can perceive are gifts; curiosity is a gift; the ancient book is a gift; the community of the faithful is a gift; the teaching is a gift; the teachers are a gift; the willingness to learn is a gift; the courage to believe is a gift; perseverance in the faith is a gift; God Himself is a gift.

Thursday, May 27, 2038

Thirteen. DNA is chemistry.

DNA has been described as a blueprint, or a cookbook, or a code, or a recording. But in fact DNA is a string of molecules. DNA is chemistry. Every molecule does what it must do, according to the laws of chemistry, under the circumstances prevailing at the moment in its immediate environment. The same appears to be true of all other molecules in living organisms. If it can be shown that the outcome of a DNA process, say in reproduction, is analogous to the outcome of something contrived, like a computer code, the fact remains that DNA is chemistry, and nothing more or less. Chemistry is mechanistic, not teleological. No purpose can be found in chemistry. 


But if DNA is in fact something contrived, like a computer code, then some intelligence contrived it.  A code or a cookbook is designed to yield a certain outcome.  Either DNA is a product of Intelligent Design, or it is an outcome of the laws of chemistry.  Either God contrived DNA, or God contrived chemistry.  Either choice is open to a person with a high view of God.

Yet DNA launches and controls the processes of growth and reproduction, leading us to say for example that she has her father’s smile. Reproduction succeeds when DNA interacts with its host organism in a long, complex process that returns, approximately, to its original state. Then the process begins again. A layman gains the impression that the mechanistic influence of DNA on growth and reproduction is very complex, subtle, surprising, indirect, inefficient, often underestimated, and for the most part still undiscovered and unexplained. But the process is not beyond understanding. Small pieces of it yield, one at a time, to our powers of observation and discovery.

The chemical environment controlling and controlled by DNA is the organism and cell in which it resides. We infer encoded information in DNA by observing its effect on the organism. Without the creature, no scrutiny of the molecule would reveal hidden information. An analogy has been offered: Nothing useful can be extracted from a recording, unless one has a playback device.

It is clear that DNA experiences mutations from time to time, and that these mutations can be inherited. It seems clear that a mutation could have an observable inherited effect on subsequent generations of the organism, though many do not. It seems plausible that the effect of a single mutation could be substantial and beneficial, given the subtle and complex influence of DNA on growth. It seems, from a layman’s casual reading, that such a substantial and beneficial effect of a mutation on succeeding generations has never been observed. It seems that the available mechanistic explanation of the evolutionary process depends heavily on a long series of successful mutations. Success means that the species not only survives and transmits the mutation but that the effect of the mutation confers a survival advantage on subsequent generations of the organism.

This mechanistic model of the evolutionary process seems barely plausible as a hypothesis, and certainly not robust enough to be called a theory. It seems, again to a layman, that some other hypothesis may one day be advanced to better explain the evolutionary facts displayed in the fossil record. Finally, it seems likely that new discoveries will reveal much more about DNA and its influence on its host.

Because it experiences heritable mutations, DNA is a source of information about the biological past. DNA contributes to our understanding of What Happened.

Wednesday, May 27, 2037

Fourteen. Biologists will never observe a miracle.

It is quite certain that biologists and biochemists, examining the fine details of simple organisms or organs, will never observe a miracle. Many organisms are similar. What is discovered in one organism must be found in another. A reliable observation can be repeated. In science, a repeatable observation is not a miracle. Observations of a particular step in growth or reproduction or metabolism or healing might be described as marvelous, or baffling, or stunning, but not as miraculous. We have come to expect that all such observations will yield eventually to mechanistic explanation as the inevitable consequence of physical laws.

But if a living organism is truly unique, and constantly changing, it is not possible to repeat an observation. The ultimate example is the person, with his conscious, active brain. If we had the means to observe and describe every neuron and synapse and electron while the brain chooses and imagines and innovates and acts, we would expect no moment to be like any previous moment, and no person’s brain to be like any other. Here there is at least the possibility of a miracle. Would we find that every state in this complex electrochemical organ yields to rational explanation as a consequence of the previous state? Or would it appear that electrons are pushed around, so to speak, by some mysterious, miraculous, unidentified external forces? If the former is true, the brain appears to be a mindless mechanism. If the latter is true, the brain appears to have a mind of its own.

Our experience and intuition support the latter. Free will is not an illusion. The mind controls the body. People are responsible for their actions. But we have not observed the miracles that would seem necessary to support this view. And we may never have the practical means to put the matter to rest by direct, reliable, definitive examination of mental process.

Some have tried to escape this intellectual dilemma by invoking quantum theory. Then perhaps mental process can be imagined to be neither deterministic nor miraculous. But biologists do not find quantum physics operating where it might be observed. A respected biologist observed that the great discoveries of 20th century physics have had no influence whatever on biology. (Although others may have discovered such influence in the 21st century) And a respected physicist doubts that the brain performs quantum calculations in its exercise of what we experience as free will.

A conservative view will reject unsupported claims of quantum physical phenomena to rationalize free will, when no such phenomena have been observed. A conservative view will also reject unsupported claims of miraculous intervention in the microcosm that is the physical brain. It is unlike God to perform miracles where they cannot be seen.

What remains is the grand miracle that confronts us daily. Free will specifically, and the minds of people generally, seem like miracles inconsistent with a mechanistic universe governed by the laws of physics. Yet by God’s grace here we are.

Biologically, life appears to be physical and chemical mechanism. No window has been discovered through which free will enters. Theologically, each of us is as Sovereign God has chosen to make us. The Calvinist view sounds at first consistent with biological determinism. But the same sovereign and creating God charges each of us to look, listen, learn, choose and respond. All we know of God’s choosing is evident in an individual’s choice and response. And the process by which the individual discovers the response he will make can be a lifelong struggle.

The quest for a functional description of the human brain is one of the greatest scientific challenges of our time. It would be a great mistake to abandon the project because free will seems to be miraculous. It would be a mistake to assume that biology cannot account for the rich consciousness of the experience of the mind. But, we have a long way to go in this particular journey of discovery.

Evolution, like free will, is a fact that confronts us. Living species appear from time to time in the fossil record. Our own species appeared in a window of time. Species have predecessors in time that are more or less similar, yet not the same. The most enthusiastic rationalists among us are hard-pressed to explain, mechanistically, how all this occurs. Narratives are set forth that are unsupported, or only weakly supported, by observations. What passes for mechanistic theory is broad and speculative.

Yet the occasional bits of genuine observation supporting mechanisms of evolution, when they appear, are invariably consistent with physical principles. Micro miracles of evolutionary progress are not reported or reliably observed. A conservative interpretation of the evidence might conclude that biology in the past, like biology in the present, is not a series of miraculous events. And again, it would be unlike God to perform a miracle in a primeval tide pool that is inaccessible to the eyes of people. Yet without such miracles, life seems like a very improbable outcome of cosmic events.

Some scientific rationalists imagine there is a still undiscovered set of physical laws, whereby the capable elements in a lifeless environment will tend to organize themselves into living structures. Then life on distant planets can be viewed not as improbable but as nearly inevitable. But good science does not invoke principles not yet discovered to explain observations not yet made.

Apart from life’s origin and evolution, the miracle that confronts us daily is life itself. Hopefully, optimistically, enthusiastically, there seems to be no end to what can be learned about life through scientific inquiry and observation and disciplined thinking. At the same time, the work of God, the miracle of life, remains at its core a mystery. Our choice is to receive the grand miracle full-on from the hand of God, or to imagine there is a materialistic, mechanistic rationalization which however eludes us and diminishes us and is contrary to our experience.