Wednesday, October 18, 2023

Twenty-nine. Truth is a categorical imperative...

Truth is a categorical imperative, according the ethical philosophy of Immanuel Kant. Because Truth is Right, a lie is wrong. Kant elevated the Right and rejected the opposite. He resisted the notion that particular circumstances might justify the lie.

Kant was challenged in his time with the hypothesis of the Inquiring Murderer, in which a truthful answer will betray the murderer’s innocent victim. The more recent version of the dilemma would have the Nazis at the door and the Jews in the attic. Kant defended his intellectual edifice and rejected the lie, while refusing to be pushed into the hypothetical corner that must choose betrayal. His critics found his position unsatisfactory.

Most people then and now would agree that truth is right, but betrayal is wrong, and in these hypothetical circumstances the betrayal is so appalling and the lie so harmless that one must choose the lie. There is no categorical imperative. The ethical choice of truth or lie depends on the situation.

This much-discussed subject is raised here to introduce a question of interest to Christians. What would Jesus do?  We do not need to speculate recklessly. We have the guidance of many Gospel stories recounting what Jesus actually did in various circumstances. The answer to our question will be one that is consistent with all that we already know. If we can write a story that would raise no eyebrows in the Christian community, then we will gain some insight into what Jesus would do an encounter with the Inquiring Murderer.

The infant Jesus was himself the target of an Inquiring Murderer. The circumstances of his birth in Bethlehem identified him as a king, a contender for the throne. The enthroned king responded to this threat by ordering the death of every infant boy in Bethlehem. Jesus’ parents, warned in a dream, escaped to Egypt. We understand from this story that the infant Jesus’ life was preserved by the power of God.

Similarly the infant Moses in Egypt would have died under Pharaoh’s edict against male Hebrew infants. Pharaoh wished to control an alien population. Moses was spared by a benign deception, in which the saving hand of God is discerned by the faithful.

So we will put the Inquiring Murderer hypothesis in Jesus' time, and suppose that the adult Jesus is in a house when soldiers appear at the door, demanding to know what children are in the house. Their grim mission is understood.

Jesus is seldom alone; those with him might include his host, his disciples, followers, seekers and so forth. There would be more than one soldier, because one alone might shirk his duty. One would speak, and all eyes would turn to Jesus to give an answer. Jesus’ wisdom and authority were unquestioned by those who knew him. How would Jesus answer?

Jesus would not lie. The Christian community would consider it blasphemous to suggest Jesus would countenance a lie, let alone tell one. No Gospel story puts a lie in Jesus’ mouth. Other Biblical characters, like Rahab, did lie in similar circumstances. Rahab was honored for her refusal to betray. But Jesus would not lie. Neither would he betray.

Jesus would respond to the soldiers, the two or three of them, with words that revealed their hearts. This is typically the way he responded to strangers. He knew the hearts of men. He would expose the evil they sought to do. Each of them would know that he saw right through them, as we might say today. Each would respond to him by confirming what Jesus’ words had revealed. The hard heart would be angry or contemptuous; another might be dismayed or sorrowful. But we will not suppose that this revelation deters the soldiers. They are all hardened men, trained do their duty. One leads and the others follow. They burst into the house and search every room.

The last line in our story will say “Finding nothing, they went on their way.” We will be left to guess whether the child that had been in the house was whisked away by the power of God, or taken out the back by a quick-thinking nanny. Or perhaps one soldier, cut to the quick by the words of Jesus, saw the sleeping child but said nothing.

If our story is true to the Gospel accounts, the faithful will read it as one more account of the power of God that is in Jesus Christ. He is able to save. No one is able to take his own from him. Whoever is in his care is in God’s care.

So we have an answer to the question, What would Jesus do? But Jesus’ followers must still answer, What would I do?

Some insist they would do as Jesus did. They will not lie to save a life; they will trust God to save the life. Kant would approve, but Kant was an old man in his study. Kant did not need to invoke the power of God to defend his thesis, because no actual life was at stake. But a follower of Jesus cannot do as Jesus did in real circumstances unless he is assured that the power of God is in his hands and will and words. Misguided individuals sometimes act as if they had such assurance when they do not.

The vast majority of Jesus’ followers will not do as our story would have Jesus do. They will lie to avoid the betrayal, as Rahab did. Many wish to follow in the steps of Jesus. Some stay with him much longer than others, but no one is with him to the end. It is not just a question of knowing what to do, or having the courage to do it. We also lack the strength, or the power, to do what Jesus alone can do. He is perfect in all respects; we are imperfect in many. We fail to emulate Christ. Instead, we worship him. God alone is good; we are not.  Jesus saves; we cannot.

Jesus’ moral teaching is, to say the least, difficult to follow. Who will bear witness to the truth?  Who will love his enemy, and turn the other cheek, and give up all his possessions for Christ’s sake? Nearly every Christian will equivocate on these, believing it necessary, but Jesus did not equivocate. He lived his teaching during his short life, and then he died.

Our claim to life is not ours but his: God raised him up. We are his body. His resurrection is ours. Similarly our claim to righteousness is a claim to his righteousness, not to our own. God’s high standard is beyond us, and revealed in him.

No comments:

Post a Comment