The Church, we hear, is the Bride of Christ. "Husbands, love your wives" wrote Paul, "as Christ loved the Church, and gave himself for her." The metaphor is instructive.
The Son left his Father's home and came seeking his Bride. He found her among us, the lost. He came to seek and save the lost. She is gathered from those of us who were lost, but are found. He became flesh, and dwelt among us, and proclaimed his Church, and claimed his Bride.
The world challenged his claim, and crucified him. His Father raised him up, and called him home. The Church now waits for the one to whom she is betrothed.
She is faithful in her betrothal, as she kneels at the foot of the cross. She worships no other than her Lord. Yet she lives in the world, passing through it and scarred by it and too often yielding to it. She is decidedly imperfect. The Bridegroom, on the other hand, is perfect. He is the Son of God.
In time, or at the end of time, she approaches the gate of Heaven. She waits in her accustomed place, on her knees at the cross of Christ. In her faithfulness she has endured to the end. In her imperfection, her sinfulness, she is scarred and stained. How shall she be found worthy?
Someone, perhaps an angel, brings her a wedding gown. It is a gift from the Father. It is the righteousness of Christ. She puts it on, like a garment. By God's gift she is made perfect. She stands up beside the Son and before the Father without stain or blemish, again as Paul wrote. Love has conquered. Where is her accuser? If God is for her, who shall be against her?
The metaphor invokes a first-century betrothal and wedding, perhaps not a modern one. And betrothal is just a metaphor. At the heart of the message is the Church's adequate measure of faithfulness, and God's adequate measure of love. God and sinner are reconciled. Marriage is not the point. Gender is beside the point. Time and place are blurred. The material and the spiritual are not separated. The relationship between the Church and the individual is not elaborated in this metaphor, though it is in others. Sin and imperfection are unworthy of God, but these failings of the Church are swept aside by love and faithfulness and the righteousness of Christ. The message is good and true and eternal. This is the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
The words of Scripture stimulate the imagination, and the imagination assembles bits of Scripture into a story like this. The story is true, theologically speaking, if it does not misrepresent the character of God.
Monday, December 15, 2025
Monday, December 16, 2024
Twenty-seven. God harbors intent.
God harbors intent. God intended to create, and here we are. God intended to draw people to himself, and to that end he has sent Jesus Christ. God reveals himself to the faithful as one who pursues ends that he envisions and intends to pursue.
We speculate that even the higher animals may harbor intent. But, lacking sufficient imagination, they do not envision any purpose beyond an immediate purpose.
People, in contrast, have imaginations that can envision very grand purposes. A person may intend to build a pyramid, or to conquer the world, and proceed to achieve that goal.
The American experiment in democracy is an example of vision, intent and achievement that was shared by many in the first generation, and appropriated enthusiastically by subsequent generations. Many great achievements of people were first envisioned by one, or a few, and subsequently by many more with a shared intent.
Is there any purpose evident in the cosmos or anywhere on earth that is not an intent first harbored by people? Many people would say that an obvious purpose of living species in nature is to reproduce their kind. Thus the purpose of an oak tree, it would seem, is to produce acorns, from which oak trees grow. Biologists caution that no intent can be located in nature. Mindless nature harbors no intent and envisions no purpose. Nature did not intend to create eagles or butterflies. Nature does not intend that these creatures live and reproduce. The fact of their survival merely creates an illusion of intent. There is no primal intent, unless intent is in the mind of God.
Did Pharaoh intend to build a pyramid, or is a pyramid just one of those things that happen from time to time in the biosphere? Humanists and theists choose the former. People envisioned a pyramid, and intended to build it, and built it. Moreover the pyramid had a purpose, whether or not we know today what it was. A scientific rationalist, on the other hand might argue that intent and purpose even in people are only illusions arising from behavior.
If vision and purpose and intent and achievement only came into full blossom with the advent of people, that is evidence of the uniqueness of people. The faithful believe that people are indeed unique; that we are created in the image of God; that we, like God, harbor intent; that God intends to accomplish even more than people have imagined; and that God’s ability to accomplish what he intends is infinitely greater than ours.
God called Abraham from his ancestral home to become the father of a great nation in a new land. Moreover, said God, through you all the people of the earth will be blessed. Thus God revealed to Abraham the purpose of his life.
Many people today would say their life has a purpose. Some inner voice, a part of an individual’s outlook, understands a purpose which might focus on care and nurture of others, or on elevation of the self, or on preservation of nature, or discovery of truth, or pursuit of experience, or some other endeavor or achievement.
All of those who worship the God of Abraham may be united in this: That they seek to serve God by living life under God’s direction and according to God’s purpose.
We speculate that even the higher animals may harbor intent. But, lacking sufficient imagination, they do not envision any purpose beyond an immediate purpose.
People, in contrast, have imaginations that can envision very grand purposes. A person may intend to build a pyramid, or to conquer the world, and proceed to achieve that goal.
The American experiment in democracy is an example of vision, intent and achievement that was shared by many in the first generation, and appropriated enthusiastically by subsequent generations. Many great achievements of people were first envisioned by one, or a few, and subsequently by many more with a shared intent.
Is there any purpose evident in the cosmos or anywhere on earth that is not an intent first harbored by people? Many people would say that an obvious purpose of living species in nature is to reproduce their kind. Thus the purpose of an oak tree, it would seem, is to produce acorns, from which oak trees grow. Biologists caution that no intent can be located in nature. Mindless nature harbors no intent and envisions no purpose. Nature did not intend to create eagles or butterflies. Nature does not intend that these creatures live and reproduce. The fact of their survival merely creates an illusion of intent. There is no primal intent, unless intent is in the mind of God.
Did Pharaoh intend to build a pyramid, or is a pyramid just one of those things that happen from time to time in the biosphere? Humanists and theists choose the former. People envisioned a pyramid, and intended to build it, and built it. Moreover the pyramid had a purpose, whether or not we know today what it was. A scientific rationalist, on the other hand might argue that intent and purpose even in people are only illusions arising from behavior.
If vision and purpose and intent and achievement only came into full blossom with the advent of people, that is evidence of the uniqueness of people. The faithful believe that people are indeed unique; that we are created in the image of God; that we, like God, harbor intent; that God intends to accomplish even more than people have imagined; and that God’s ability to accomplish what he intends is infinitely greater than ours.
God called Abraham from his ancestral home to become the father of a great nation in a new land. Moreover, said God, through you all the people of the earth will be blessed. Thus God revealed to Abraham the purpose of his life.
Many people today would say their life has a purpose. Some inner voice, a part of an individual’s outlook, understands a purpose which might focus on care and nurture of others, or on elevation of the self, or on preservation of nature, or discovery of truth, or pursuit of experience, or some other endeavor or achievement.
All of those who worship the God of Abraham may be united in this: That they seek to serve God by living life under God’s direction and according to God’s purpose.
Friday, October 20, 2023
Twenty-eight. In mechanics...
In mechanics, work is produced by a following force. Force causes motion, and the product of the two is work. When force stops, work stops, though motion may continue. Work, like heat, is a form of energy. The customary units of work are foot-pounds, or Newton-meters if you prefer.
Most people find power more interesting than work. Power is the rate of doing work. We can think of power as latent and potential, lurking under the hood, or power as manifest, a visible display of force and energy.
James Watt wished to claim that his newly invented steam engine could do the work of several horses. To support his claim he measured the power of a horse by various means. For example in 1783 he showed that a horse walking at 2.5 miles per hour could easily raise a 100 pound weight out of a well, using a rope and pulley. Two and a half miles per hour is 220 feet per minute. So, this horse was working at the rate of 22,000 foot-pounds per minute. Other experiments convinced Watt that this estimate was too low, so he increased the number by 50% and arrived at 33,000 foot-pounds per minute as a reasonable estimate of the power of a horse. This is the definition of horsepower still in use.
A small horse can produce one horsepower for a time, but horse handlers report that even a large horse will tire if required to do a day’s work at this rate. Unlike Watt’s engine, people and animals grow tired when they work. Yet we can do work at a high rate for a short time.
If an athlete weighing 110 pounds can run up stairs at the rate of 5 feet of vertical ascent per second, this very vigorous individual is producing one horsepower. If the athlete weighs 220 pounds, he only needs to ascend at 2.5 feet per second to produce one horsepower. One horsepower may be easy for a horse, but it is near the upper limit of a human athlete’s short-term capability.
In 1997 the bicyclist Marco Pantani ascended an Alpine grade of 8.89 miles in a record time of 37 minutes 35 seconds. The vertical ascent was 3749 feet. Pantani reportedly weighed 126 pounds, and his bicycle 15 pounds. If we do the math we find that he produced on average 0.43 horsepower in making this ascent. But his gear might have added a little more weight, and wind resistance at 15 miles per hour would have called for a little more power. We can reasonably claim that this athlete produced about half a horsepower for about half an hour. It might be hard to find an example of greater power produced by any person for a comparable length of time, especially if we ask for horsepower per pound of body weight.
Every moving thing is moved by a force, or was moved by force at the outset of its motion. If we ask narrowly what is moving, and what caused that motion, the answers will invoke virtually all of the physical sciences and will identify all of the forces of nature.
We will also identify artifacts that move by design, like vehicles, boats, motors and projectiles. Sometimes we employ natural forces, like the wind, to move those artifacts. More often we devise an artificial way to produce the force and do the work. We can list all the practical sources of main force. They are
• Living tissue: muscle power.
• Gravity: for example, descending water.
• Magnetism and electromagnetism, as employed for example in electric motors.
• Elasticity: The wound spring or compressed gas, in which force is applied now and recovered later.
• Dynamic force arising from Newton’s second law, in which the velocity of some mass is altered. Greater mass, or greater altering, generates greater force. This force propels a leaf blowing in the wind, or a sailboat.
• Thermal expansion, including the expansion of hot gas as typically harnessed in engines. There are various ways, including combustion and detonation and nuclear fission, to produce the hot gas.
Electrostatic force is difficult to harness but is occasionally put to use. Osmotic pressure can lift a liquid, however slowly. Nuclear physics identifies small-scale forces that have not been put to use by engineers. Cosmologists speculate about large-scale forces that are not perceptible here on earth.
One method commonly employed to move a vehicle or other object is to purchase traction on the surface of the earth, and push or pull. The horse’s hoof and the powered wheel on pavement are two examples. The gondolier’s pole on the bottom of the canal is another. In each case a force is applied to the earth. Because the earth is immovable, or nearly so, the vehicle moves and the force follows with it.
Another way to move an object forward is to accelerate fluid aft. This is a concise description of the mechanism that propels a rowboat, a rocket, a propeller-driven ship or plane, a jet plane, a turbine and a sailboat.
The working fluid might be air, or water, or some gaseous product of combustion. To accelerate the fluid is to change its velocity. Velocity has both a direction and a magnitude. To accelerate a fluid aft is to thrust it backward, or to give it a new direction that is more nearly backward. By Newton’s Second Law, the force that accelerates the fluid backward will be the product of mass and acceleration. By Newton’s Third Law, the rearward force on the fluid will be matched by a forward force on the vehicle.
The rocket motor, for example, accelerates its gaseous inventory straight back at high velocity as it burns. The rocket is perhaps the simplest example of driving a vehicle forward by accelerating fluid aft.
A more complex and more instructive example is the sailboat.
First consider a sailboat running before the wind. The sails do not reverse the direction of the wind and send it aft. The following wind is not even stopped; it is merely slowed. But that slowing is acceleration toward the stern, and Newton’s Second Law will quantify the force that drives the sailboat forward by accelerating wind aft.
Now consider a sailboat steering east on a north wind. The course is called a reach. The sailor sets the sail to capture wind from the north and bend it toward the west, which is aft. Because the boat is making headway east, the wind seems to be coming not from due north but from east of north. The leading edge of the sail must point directly into this wind, for any other set would slow the wind and slow the boat. The trailing edge of the sail points aft, or nearly aft. Lines tied aft are taut. The boat is pulled forward.
It is obvious that wind entering the windward or inside curve of the sail must turn aft, following the curve. But the front side of the sail has a positive curvature. It is not so obvious that wind passing in front of the sail will be turned aft, but in fact it is. Explanations usually note that the outside of the sail is curved like an airplane wing; it is an airfoil. Air passes over an airfoil and creates a low pressure which is called lift. Lift in front of the sail pulls the craft forward. All this is true, but it is also true that the low pressure on the front surface of the sail causes air to accelerate back toward the sail, which is aft. The Newtonian description of the sail’s function remains valid.
Now suppose the sailor steers a few degrees north of east, angling into the wind. The course is called a tack or beat. As long as the boat is making headway the sailor can steer the course. The keel and rudder will overcome any tendency of the wind to move the sailboat sideways. The interaction of wind and sail is not fundamentally different from the reach. But now the apparent wind direction is closer to the bow, and more nearly due aft, so less turning of the wind is possible and therefore less reaction force is available to drive the boat forward. Also, the force of the wind against the hull and rigging is farther forward, working against headway. At some point as the sailor steers ever closer to the wind, setting the sail’s leading edge more nearly forward, the sailboat can no longer make headway.
The familiar three-bladed wind turbine is like a sailboat on a reach. The similarity is not in form, but in function. The blade, like the sail, moves at a right angle to the wind. The blade’s shape and set are designed to turn the wind aft, opposite to the direction of rotation.
To think about the blade’s shape and set, imagine each blade is a row of sails attached by rigging to a mast. Three masts with their rows of sails form the wind turbine’s rotor. We will engage a sailor to ride each mast in a boson’s chair and to set each sail as he would do on a sailboat.
Imagine the sailor faces the direction of rotation. The wind is from his left. At a location near the hub, the rotational speed of the blade might be about equal to the wind speed. Then the wind will appear to be coming not from the left, but from the left front at 45 degrees. The sailor will set the leading edge of this inboard sail at 45 degrees, and fasten the trailing edge so that it curves back toward himself. Wind enters the sail and turns aft, pushing the mast forward.
As the sailor moves up the mast, the speed in the direction of rotation increases while the wind speed remains constant. The apparent wind direction moves closer to the front. At the last sail location, corresponding to the blade tip, the blade speed might be five or six times the wind velocity. Then the wind will appear to be coming from only about ten degrees left of the direction of motion. The sail is set accordingly. The contribution of the blade tip to the work of the wind turbine is obtained by turning the wind through an angle of only ten degrees. That is not a lot of turning, but on the other hand there is a great deal of air to be turned at this distance from the hub.
No sailboat on a reach achieves a forward velocity of even twice the wind speed. The hull and keel, as well as the mast and rigging, all create drag forces that limit the speed. An iceboat can achieve five times the wind speed, because drag forces are much smaller. The well-designed wind turbine blade produces so little drag that it can still generate net force in the direction of rotation at a speed six times the wind speed.
Our row of sails will not make a satisfactory turbine blade, because these sails cannot be continuously reset as the wind changes. Sails would luff when the wind speed drops. The apparent wind direction would move farther forward and shake or collapse the leading edge of the sails. The actual blade will have a fixed shape that is strong and rigid, and it will have a leading edge that is blunt like an airplane wing, rather than thin like a sail. The blunt leading edge and rigid airfoil shape make the blade stable, tolerant of changes in the wind speed, still producing net forward force under varying conditions. The blade’s airfoil shape will be twisted, like the row of sails, which we set at 45 degrees near the hub and only 10 degrees at the tip.
Having discussed acceleration of fluids, one might ask why acceleration of solids is not also a useful way to generate a force and propel an object. Examples are few, because acceleration of solids is inconvenient compared to acceleration of liquids and gases. But consider a rifle firing a bullet. Hot pressurized gas is generated by detonation in the chamber. The bullet is accelerated forward, and the rifle backward, each at a rate inversely proportional to its mass. The pressurized gas in the barrel merely transmits force between bullet and rifle. We can say that the bullet moves forward by accelerating the rifle aft. Or from the rifle’s perspective, the bullet is accelerated aft.
Now suppose the rifle butt is placed securely against a large boulder. The rifle does not move when it is fired. The rifle moves the bullet forward by securing a foothold on the earth, and pushing, just as the horse moves the cart forward by planting a hoof and pushing. We are back to Newton’s third law, not needing the second law to explain why the bullet leaves the barrel.
Most people find power more interesting than work. Power is the rate of doing work. We can think of power as latent and potential, lurking under the hood, or power as manifest, a visible display of force and energy.
James Watt wished to claim that his newly invented steam engine could do the work of several horses. To support his claim he measured the power of a horse by various means. For example in 1783 he showed that a horse walking at 2.5 miles per hour could easily raise a 100 pound weight out of a well, using a rope and pulley. Two and a half miles per hour is 220 feet per minute. So, this horse was working at the rate of 22,000 foot-pounds per minute. Other experiments convinced Watt that this estimate was too low, so he increased the number by 50% and arrived at 33,000 foot-pounds per minute as a reasonable estimate of the power of a horse. This is the definition of horsepower still in use.
A small horse can produce one horsepower for a time, but horse handlers report that even a large horse will tire if required to do a day’s work at this rate. Unlike Watt’s engine, people and animals grow tired when they work. Yet we can do work at a high rate for a short time.
If an athlete weighing 110 pounds can run up stairs at the rate of 5 feet of vertical ascent per second, this very vigorous individual is producing one horsepower. If the athlete weighs 220 pounds, he only needs to ascend at 2.5 feet per second to produce one horsepower. One horsepower may be easy for a horse, but it is near the upper limit of a human athlete’s short-term capability.
In 1997 the bicyclist Marco Pantani ascended an Alpine grade of 8.89 miles in a record time of 37 minutes 35 seconds. The vertical ascent was 3749 feet. Pantani reportedly weighed 126 pounds, and his bicycle 15 pounds. If we do the math we find that he produced on average 0.43 horsepower in making this ascent. But his gear might have added a little more weight, and wind resistance at 15 miles per hour would have called for a little more power. We can reasonably claim that this athlete produced about half a horsepower for about half an hour. It might be hard to find an example of greater power produced by any person for a comparable length of time, especially if we ask for horsepower per pound of body weight.
Every moving thing is moved by a force, or was moved by force at the outset of its motion. If we ask narrowly what is moving, and what caused that motion, the answers will invoke virtually all of the physical sciences and will identify all of the forces of nature.
We will also identify artifacts that move by design, like vehicles, boats, motors and projectiles. Sometimes we employ natural forces, like the wind, to move those artifacts. More often we devise an artificial way to produce the force and do the work. We can list all the practical sources of main force. They are
• Living tissue: muscle power.
• Gravity: for example, descending water.
• Magnetism and electromagnetism, as employed for example in electric motors.
• Elasticity: The wound spring or compressed gas, in which force is applied now and recovered later.
• Dynamic force arising from Newton’s second law, in which the velocity of some mass is altered. Greater mass, or greater altering, generates greater force. This force propels a leaf blowing in the wind, or a sailboat.
• Thermal expansion, including the expansion of hot gas as typically harnessed in engines. There are various ways, including combustion and detonation and nuclear fission, to produce the hot gas.
Electrostatic force is difficult to harness but is occasionally put to use. Osmotic pressure can lift a liquid, however slowly. Nuclear physics identifies small-scale forces that have not been put to use by engineers. Cosmologists speculate about large-scale forces that are not perceptible here on earth.
One method commonly employed to move a vehicle or other object is to purchase traction on the surface of the earth, and push or pull. The horse’s hoof and the powered wheel on pavement are two examples. The gondolier’s pole on the bottom of the canal is another. In each case a force is applied to the earth. Because the earth is immovable, or nearly so, the vehicle moves and the force follows with it.
Another way to move an object forward is to accelerate fluid aft. This is a concise description of the mechanism that propels a rowboat, a rocket, a propeller-driven ship or plane, a jet plane, a turbine and a sailboat.
The working fluid might be air, or water, or some gaseous product of combustion. To accelerate the fluid is to change its velocity. Velocity has both a direction and a magnitude. To accelerate a fluid aft is to thrust it backward, or to give it a new direction that is more nearly backward. By Newton’s Second Law, the force that accelerates the fluid backward will be the product of mass and acceleration. By Newton’s Third Law, the rearward force on the fluid will be matched by a forward force on the vehicle.
The rocket motor, for example, accelerates its gaseous inventory straight back at high velocity as it burns. The rocket is perhaps the simplest example of driving a vehicle forward by accelerating fluid aft.
A more complex and more instructive example is the sailboat.
First consider a sailboat running before the wind. The sails do not reverse the direction of the wind and send it aft. The following wind is not even stopped; it is merely slowed. But that slowing is acceleration toward the stern, and Newton’s Second Law will quantify the force that drives the sailboat forward by accelerating wind aft.
Now consider a sailboat steering east on a north wind. The course is called a reach. The sailor sets the sail to capture wind from the north and bend it toward the west, which is aft. Because the boat is making headway east, the wind seems to be coming not from due north but from east of north. The leading edge of the sail must point directly into this wind, for any other set would slow the wind and slow the boat. The trailing edge of the sail points aft, or nearly aft. Lines tied aft are taut. The boat is pulled forward.
It is obvious that wind entering the windward or inside curve of the sail must turn aft, following the curve. But the front side of the sail has a positive curvature. It is not so obvious that wind passing in front of the sail will be turned aft, but in fact it is. Explanations usually note that the outside of the sail is curved like an airplane wing; it is an airfoil. Air passes over an airfoil and creates a low pressure which is called lift. Lift in front of the sail pulls the craft forward. All this is true, but it is also true that the low pressure on the front surface of the sail causes air to accelerate back toward the sail, which is aft. The Newtonian description of the sail’s function remains valid.
Now suppose the sailor steers a few degrees north of east, angling into the wind. The course is called a tack or beat. As long as the boat is making headway the sailor can steer the course. The keel and rudder will overcome any tendency of the wind to move the sailboat sideways. The interaction of wind and sail is not fundamentally different from the reach. But now the apparent wind direction is closer to the bow, and more nearly due aft, so less turning of the wind is possible and therefore less reaction force is available to drive the boat forward. Also, the force of the wind against the hull and rigging is farther forward, working against headway. At some point as the sailor steers ever closer to the wind, setting the sail’s leading edge more nearly forward, the sailboat can no longer make headway.
The familiar three-bladed wind turbine is like a sailboat on a reach. The similarity is not in form, but in function. The blade, like the sail, moves at a right angle to the wind. The blade’s shape and set are designed to turn the wind aft, opposite to the direction of rotation.
To think about the blade’s shape and set, imagine each blade is a row of sails attached by rigging to a mast. Three masts with their rows of sails form the wind turbine’s rotor. We will engage a sailor to ride each mast in a boson’s chair and to set each sail as he would do on a sailboat.
Imagine the sailor faces the direction of rotation. The wind is from his left. At a location near the hub, the rotational speed of the blade might be about equal to the wind speed. Then the wind will appear to be coming not from the left, but from the left front at 45 degrees. The sailor will set the leading edge of this inboard sail at 45 degrees, and fasten the trailing edge so that it curves back toward himself. Wind enters the sail and turns aft, pushing the mast forward.
As the sailor moves up the mast, the speed in the direction of rotation increases while the wind speed remains constant. The apparent wind direction moves closer to the front. At the last sail location, corresponding to the blade tip, the blade speed might be five or six times the wind velocity. Then the wind will appear to be coming from only about ten degrees left of the direction of motion. The sail is set accordingly. The contribution of the blade tip to the work of the wind turbine is obtained by turning the wind through an angle of only ten degrees. That is not a lot of turning, but on the other hand there is a great deal of air to be turned at this distance from the hub.
No sailboat on a reach achieves a forward velocity of even twice the wind speed. The hull and keel, as well as the mast and rigging, all create drag forces that limit the speed. An iceboat can achieve five times the wind speed, because drag forces are much smaller. The well-designed wind turbine blade produces so little drag that it can still generate net force in the direction of rotation at a speed six times the wind speed.
Our row of sails will not make a satisfactory turbine blade, because these sails cannot be continuously reset as the wind changes. Sails would luff when the wind speed drops. The apparent wind direction would move farther forward and shake or collapse the leading edge of the sails. The actual blade will have a fixed shape that is strong and rigid, and it will have a leading edge that is blunt like an airplane wing, rather than thin like a sail. The blunt leading edge and rigid airfoil shape make the blade stable, tolerant of changes in the wind speed, still producing net forward force under varying conditions. The blade’s airfoil shape will be twisted, like the row of sails, which we set at 45 degrees near the hub and only 10 degrees at the tip.
Having discussed acceleration of fluids, one might ask why acceleration of solids is not also a useful way to generate a force and propel an object. Examples are few, because acceleration of solids is inconvenient compared to acceleration of liquids and gases. But consider a rifle firing a bullet. Hot pressurized gas is generated by detonation in the chamber. The bullet is accelerated forward, and the rifle backward, each at a rate inversely proportional to its mass. The pressurized gas in the barrel merely transmits force between bullet and rifle. We can say that the bullet moves forward by accelerating the rifle aft. Or from the rifle’s perspective, the bullet is accelerated aft.
Now suppose the rifle butt is placed securely against a large boulder. The rifle does not move when it is fired. The rifle moves the bullet forward by securing a foothold on the earth, and pushing, just as the horse moves the cart forward by planting a hoof and pushing. We are back to Newton’s third law, not needing the second law to explain why the bullet leaves the barrel.
Wednesday, October 18, 2023
Twenty-nine. Truth is a categorical imperative...
Truth is a categorical imperative, according the ethical philosophy of Immanuel Kant. Because Truth is Right, a lie is wrong. Kant elevated the Right and rejected the opposite. He resisted the notion that particular circumstances might justify the lie.
Kant was challenged in his time with the hypothesis of the Inquiring Murderer, in which a truthful answer will betray the murderer’s innocent victim. The more recent version of the dilemma would have the Nazis at the door and the Jews in the attic. Kant defended his intellectual edifice and rejected the lie, while refusing to be pushed into the hypothetical corner that must choose betrayal. His critics found his position unsatisfactory.
Most people then and now would agree that truth is right, but betrayal is wrong, and in these hypothetical circumstances the betrayal is so appalling and the lie so harmless that one must choose the lie. There is no categorical imperative. The ethical choice of truth or lie depends on the situation.
This much-discussed subject is raised here to introduce a question of interest to Christians. What would Jesus do? We do not need to speculate recklessly. We have the guidance of many Gospel stories recounting what Jesus actually did in various circumstances. The answer to our question will be one that is consistent with all that we already know. If we can write a story that would raise no eyebrows in the Christian community, then we will gain some insight into what Jesus would do an encounter with the Inquiring Murderer.
The infant Jesus was himself the target of an Inquiring Murderer. The circumstances of his birth in Bethlehem identified him as a king, a contender for the throne. The enthroned king responded to this threat by ordering the death of every infant boy in Bethlehem. Jesus’ parents, warned in a dream, escaped to Egypt. We understand from this story that the infant Jesus’ life was preserved by the power of God.
Similarly the infant Moses in Egypt would have died under Pharaoh’s edict against male Hebrew infants. Pharaoh wished to control an alien population. Moses was spared by a benign deception, in which the saving hand of God is discerned by the faithful.
So we will put the Inquiring Murderer hypothesis in Jesus' time, and suppose that the adult Jesus is in a house when soldiers appear at the door, demanding to know what children are in the house. Their grim mission is understood.
Jesus is seldom alone; those with him might include his host, his disciples, followers, seekers and so forth. There would be more than one soldier, because one alone might shirk his duty. One would speak, and all eyes would turn to Jesus to give an answer. Jesus’ wisdom and authority were unquestioned by those who knew him. How would Jesus answer?
Jesus would not lie. The Christian community would consider it blasphemous to suggest Jesus would countenance a lie, let alone tell one. No Gospel story puts a lie in Jesus’ mouth. Other Biblical characters, like Rahab, did lie in similar circumstances. Rahab was honored for her refusal to betray. But Jesus would not lie. Neither would he betray.
Jesus would respond to the soldiers, the two or three of them, with words that revealed their hearts. This is typically the way he responded to strangers. He knew the hearts of men. He would expose the evil they sought to do. Each of them would know that he saw right through them, as we might say today. Each would respond to him by confirming what Jesus’ words had revealed. The hard heart would be angry or contemptuous; another might be dismayed or sorrowful. But we will not suppose that this revelation deters the soldiers. They are all hardened men, trained do their duty. One leads and the others follow. They burst into the house and search every room.
The last line in our story will say “Finding nothing, they went on their way.” We will be left to guess whether the child that had been in the house was whisked away by the power of God, or taken out the back by a quick-thinking nanny. Or perhaps one soldier, cut to the quick by the words of Jesus, saw the sleeping child but said nothing.
If our story is true to the Gospel accounts, the faithful will read it as one more account of the power of God that is in Jesus Christ. He is able to save. No one is able to take his own from him. Whoever is in his care is in God’s care.
So we have an answer to the question, What would Jesus do? But Jesus’ followers must still answer, What would I do?
Some insist they would do as Jesus did. They will not lie to save a life; they will trust God to save the life. Kant would approve, but Kant was an old man in his study. Kant did not need to invoke the power of God to defend his thesis, because no actual life was at stake. But a follower of Jesus cannot do as Jesus did in real circumstances unless he is assured that the power of God is in his hands and will and words. Misguided individuals sometimes act as if they had such assurance when they do not.
The vast majority of Jesus’ followers will not do as our story would have Jesus do. They will lie to avoid the betrayal, as Rahab did. Many wish to follow in the steps of Jesus. Some stay with him much longer than others, but no one is with him to the end. It is not just a question of knowing what to do, or having the courage to do it. We also lack the strength, or the power, to do what Jesus alone can do. He is perfect in all respects; we are imperfect in many. We fail to emulate Christ. Instead, we worship him. God alone is good; we are not. Jesus saves; we cannot.
Jesus’ moral teaching is, to say the least, difficult to follow. Who will bear witness to the truth? Who will love his enemy, and turn the other cheek, and give up all his possessions for Christ’s sake? Nearly every Christian will equivocate on these, believing it necessary, but Jesus did not equivocate. He lived his teaching during his short life, and then he died.
Our claim to life is not ours but his: God raised him up. We are his body. His resurrection is ours. Similarly our claim to righteousness is a claim to his righteousness, not to our own. God’s high standard is beyond us, and revealed in him.
Kant was challenged in his time with the hypothesis of the Inquiring Murderer, in which a truthful answer will betray the murderer’s innocent victim. The more recent version of the dilemma would have the Nazis at the door and the Jews in the attic. Kant defended his intellectual edifice and rejected the lie, while refusing to be pushed into the hypothetical corner that must choose betrayal. His critics found his position unsatisfactory.
Most people then and now would agree that truth is right, but betrayal is wrong, and in these hypothetical circumstances the betrayal is so appalling and the lie so harmless that one must choose the lie. There is no categorical imperative. The ethical choice of truth or lie depends on the situation.
This much-discussed subject is raised here to introduce a question of interest to Christians. What would Jesus do? We do not need to speculate recklessly. We have the guidance of many Gospel stories recounting what Jesus actually did in various circumstances. The answer to our question will be one that is consistent with all that we already know. If we can write a story that would raise no eyebrows in the Christian community, then we will gain some insight into what Jesus would do an encounter with the Inquiring Murderer.
The infant Jesus was himself the target of an Inquiring Murderer. The circumstances of his birth in Bethlehem identified him as a king, a contender for the throne. The enthroned king responded to this threat by ordering the death of every infant boy in Bethlehem. Jesus’ parents, warned in a dream, escaped to Egypt. We understand from this story that the infant Jesus’ life was preserved by the power of God.
Similarly the infant Moses in Egypt would have died under Pharaoh’s edict against male Hebrew infants. Pharaoh wished to control an alien population. Moses was spared by a benign deception, in which the saving hand of God is discerned by the faithful.
So we will put the Inquiring Murderer hypothesis in Jesus' time, and suppose that the adult Jesus is in a house when soldiers appear at the door, demanding to know what children are in the house. Their grim mission is understood.
Jesus is seldom alone; those with him might include his host, his disciples, followers, seekers and so forth. There would be more than one soldier, because one alone might shirk his duty. One would speak, and all eyes would turn to Jesus to give an answer. Jesus’ wisdom and authority were unquestioned by those who knew him. How would Jesus answer?
Jesus would not lie. The Christian community would consider it blasphemous to suggest Jesus would countenance a lie, let alone tell one. No Gospel story puts a lie in Jesus’ mouth. Other Biblical characters, like Rahab, did lie in similar circumstances. Rahab was honored for her refusal to betray. But Jesus would not lie. Neither would he betray.
Jesus would respond to the soldiers, the two or three of them, with words that revealed their hearts. This is typically the way he responded to strangers. He knew the hearts of men. He would expose the evil they sought to do. Each of them would know that he saw right through them, as we might say today. Each would respond to him by confirming what Jesus’ words had revealed. The hard heart would be angry or contemptuous; another might be dismayed or sorrowful. But we will not suppose that this revelation deters the soldiers. They are all hardened men, trained do their duty. One leads and the others follow. They burst into the house and search every room.
The last line in our story will say “Finding nothing, they went on their way.” We will be left to guess whether the child that had been in the house was whisked away by the power of God, or taken out the back by a quick-thinking nanny. Or perhaps one soldier, cut to the quick by the words of Jesus, saw the sleeping child but said nothing.
If our story is true to the Gospel accounts, the faithful will read it as one more account of the power of God that is in Jesus Christ. He is able to save. No one is able to take his own from him. Whoever is in his care is in God’s care.
So we have an answer to the question, What would Jesus do? But Jesus’ followers must still answer, What would I do?
Some insist they would do as Jesus did. They will not lie to save a life; they will trust God to save the life. Kant would approve, but Kant was an old man in his study. Kant did not need to invoke the power of God to defend his thesis, because no actual life was at stake. But a follower of Jesus cannot do as Jesus did in real circumstances unless he is assured that the power of God is in his hands and will and words. Misguided individuals sometimes act as if they had such assurance when they do not.
The vast majority of Jesus’ followers will not do as our story would have Jesus do. They will lie to avoid the betrayal, as Rahab did. Many wish to follow in the steps of Jesus. Some stay with him much longer than others, but no one is with him to the end. It is not just a question of knowing what to do, or having the courage to do it. We also lack the strength, or the power, to do what Jesus alone can do. He is perfect in all respects; we are imperfect in many. We fail to emulate Christ. Instead, we worship him. God alone is good; we are not. Jesus saves; we cannot.
Jesus’ moral teaching is, to say the least, difficult to follow. Who will bear witness to the truth? Who will love his enemy, and turn the other cheek, and give up all his possessions for Christ’s sake? Nearly every Christian will equivocate on these, believing it necessary, but Jesus did not equivocate. He lived his teaching during his short life, and then he died.
Our claim to life is not ours but his: God raised him up. We are his body. His resurrection is ours. Similarly our claim to righteousness is a claim to his righteousness, not to our own. God’s high standard is beyond us, and revealed in him.
Monday, October 16, 2023
Thirty. Dear Jalyse
Judy shared your letter of November 30 with me and other members of her family. Thank you for taking the time to write down your views on such an important question. With this letter I am doing something similar.
The doctrine of the Trinity is central to the Christian faith. Some say it is the central doctrine of the Christian faith. So, Christians should be prepared to defend it when called upon to do so, and that is my purpose here.
The New Testament often speaks of Father, Son and Spirit. I think you will agree that two or all three of these names often appear together in passages about God. We call these the Trinity. Our question is what is the relationship between Persons of the Trinity? To this question, different passages of scripture have been interpreted in different ways to arrive at different conclusions.
The Doctrine of the Trinity begins with the teaching that God is One. In this there is no possibility of error or misunderstanding of the teaching of Scripture. We worship the God of Abraham, and He is One. Jehovah is a name given since ancient times to the one true God.
Then each Person of the Trinity is either God, or not. The three cannot be a plurality of gods. And if one is subordinate to another, and less great, then they are not One God.
The Christian church does exalt Jesus Christ. When we must make a choice between two interpretations of Scripture, we choose the one that exalts Christ, and not the one that diminishes Him. As a man of flesh he is one of us. As God, He is true God, and not a lesser god.
We proclaim one God, one Father, one Son, one Spirit, one Savior, one King, one Judge, just to begin a list.
Yours in Him,
Joe
The doctrine of the Trinity is central to the Christian faith. Some say it is the central doctrine of the Christian faith. So, Christians should be prepared to defend it when called upon to do so, and that is my purpose here.
The New Testament often speaks of Father, Son and Spirit. I think you will agree that two or all three of these names often appear together in passages about God. We call these the Trinity. Our question is what is the relationship between Persons of the Trinity? To this question, different passages of scripture have been interpreted in different ways to arrive at different conclusions.
The Doctrine of the Trinity begins with the teaching that God is One. In this there is no possibility of error or misunderstanding of the teaching of Scripture. We worship the God of Abraham, and He is One. Jehovah is a name given since ancient times to the one true God.
Then each Person of the Trinity is either God, or not. The three cannot be a plurality of gods. And if one is subordinate to another, and less great, then they are not One God.
The Christian church does exalt Jesus Christ. When we must make a choice between two interpretations of Scripture, we choose the one that exalts Christ, and not the one that diminishes Him. As a man of flesh he is one of us. As God, He is true God, and not a lesser god.
We proclaim one God, one Father, one Son, one Spirit, one Savior, one King, one Judge, just to begin a list.
Yours in Him,
Joe
Monday, February 29, 2016
Marriage Service
Marriage
Service
Words of Gathering
God is love, and those who abide in love abide in
God, and God abides in them. This is the day the Lord has made. Let us rejoice
and be glad in it.
Greeting
Dearly beloved, we are gathered here today in God’s
presence, and in the presence of friends and loved ones, to join L and E in
holy matrimony, and to celebrate with them in one of life’s greatest moments.
Marriage is a most honorable estate, established and sanctified by God, and
signifying the union which also rests between Christ and the Church. So too may
this marriage be adorned by true and abiding love. May L and E cherish and
delight one another; may they comfort and help each other in sickness, trouble
and sorrow; may they provide for each other in temporal things; may they pray
for and encourage each other and live together as heirs of the grace of life.
Opening Prayer
Almighty and
ever-blessed God, whose presence is the happiness of every condition, and whose
favor hallows every relation: We beseech you to be present and favorable unto
these your servants, that they may be truly joined in the honorable estate of
marriage, in the covenant of their God. As you have brought them together by
your providence, sanctify them by your Spirit, giving them a heart fit for
their new estate; enrich them with all grace, whereby they may enjoy the
comforts, undergo the cares, endure the trials, and perform the duties of life
together, under your guidance and protection; through Jesus Christ we pray.
Amen.
Hymn or
song
First
Reading
Musical
interlude
Second
reading
Declaration
of intentions
L C, will you have this woman to be your wife, and
will you promise your life to her in all love and honor, in all duty and
service, in all faith and tenderness, to live with her, and cherish her
according to the ordinance of God, in the holy bond of marriage?
The
groom shall answer ‘I will’.
E H, will you have this man to be your husband, and
will you promise your life to him in all love and honor, in all duty and
service, in all faith and tenderness, to live with him, and cherish him
according to the ordinance of God, in the holy bond of marriage?
The
bride shall answer ‘I will’.
Who gives this woman to be married to this man? Or, who gives this man and woman to be
married?
Or
…?
Charge to family and friends
Each of you are here today because you are part of
the community where L and E will make their home. Therefore, having heard them
state their intentions to each other and before God in this Service of
Marriage, do you pledge to support their union and to strengthen their lives
together?
The
people shall answer ‘Yes, we do’.
Marriage vows
Here, the groom takes the bride's right hand with
his right hand, and says, after the Minister:
I, L, take you E, to be my wedded wife; And I do promise and covenant; before God and these witnesses; to be your loving and faithful husband; in plenty and in want; in joy and in sorrow; in sickness and in health; as long as we both shall live.
Then the bride takes the groom's right hand with her right hand, and says likewise after the Minister:
I, E, take you, L, to be my wedded husband; and I do promise and covenant; before God and these witnesses; to be your loving and faithful wife; in plenty and in want; in joy and in sorrow; in sickness and in health; as long as we both shall live.
I, L, take you E, to be my wedded wife; And I do promise and covenant; before God and these witnesses; to be your loving and faithful husband; in plenty and in want; in joy and in sorrow; in sickness and in health; as long as we both shall live.
Then the bride takes the groom's right hand with her right hand, and says likewise after the Minister:
I, E, take you, L, to be my wedded husband; and I do promise and covenant; before God and these witnesses; to be your loving and faithful wife; in plenty and in want; in joy and in sorrow; in sickness and in health; as long as we both shall live.
Exchange of Rings
Then the ring for bride shall be given to the
Minister, who shall pass it to the groom, who shall then put it upon the
bride's fourth finger, saying after the Minister:
This ring I give you; in token and pledge; of our constant faith; and abiding love.
Then the ring for the groom shall be given to the Minister, who shall pass it to the bride, who shall then put it upon the groom's fourth finger, saying after the Minister:
This ring I give you: in token and pledge: of our constant faith: and abiding love.
This ring I give you; in token and pledge; of our constant faith; and abiding love.
Then the ring for the groom shall be given to the Minister, who shall pass it to the bride, who shall then put it upon the groom's fourth finger, saying after the Minister:
This ring I give you: in token and pledge: of our constant faith: and abiding love.
Wedding Prayer
Let us pray.
Most merciful and gracious God, in whom we live and move and have our being, bestow upon these your servants the seal of your approval, and your benediction; granting them grace to fulfill, with pure and steadfast affection, the vow and covenant they have made. Guide them together, we ask, in the way of righteousness and peace, that, loving and serving you, with one heart and mind, all the days of their life, they may be abundantly enriched with the tokens of your everlasting favor, in Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Most merciful and gracious God, in whom we live and move and have our being, bestow upon these your servants the seal of your approval, and your benediction; granting them grace to fulfill, with pure and steadfast affection, the vow and covenant they have made. Guide them together, we ask, in the way of righteousness and peace, that, loving and serving you, with one heart and mind, all the days of their life, they may be abundantly enriched with the tokens of your everlasting favor, in Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
The Lord’s Prayer
Pronouncement of Marriage
By the authority given
to me by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, I declare that L C and E H are now
Husband and Wife, according to the ordinance of God, and the law of this State;
in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen
Then causing the bride and the groom and to join right hands,
Whom therefore God has joined together, let no one put asunder.
Then causing the bride and the groom and to join right hands,
Whom therefore God has joined together, let no one put asunder.
Benediction
The grace of Christ
attend you, and the Father’s love surround you, the Holy Spirit keep you, that
you may live in faith, abound in hope, and grow in love, now and forever. Amen.
Or,
May the grace of Christ your Savior
And the
Father’s boundless love,
With the
Holy Spirit’s favor
Rest upon
you from above.
Thus may
you abide in union
With each
other and the Lord,
And possess
in sweet communion,
Joys which
earth cannot afford.
You many kiss the bride.
Ladies and Gentlemen, it is my happy privilege to
congratulate and introduce to you
Mr. and Mrs. L C
Thursday, January 28, 2016
March 1933
Here are Virginia Nuckols and Joe Gilman at her parents’
home in Bell, California. This photo was taken probably a couple of years
before they were married on March 20, 1933. I shall refer to Virginia and Joe
as Mother and Dad.
Mother’s parents were Sam and Mae Nuckols. The Depression
closed Sam Nuckols’ plumbing business in Bell. The Nuckols family would move
from Bell to San Diego County, a hundred miles south and east, by 1933. Mother
and Dad were married at the Nuckols home, “the ranch”, in the Pauma Valley near
Pala.
They were married 10 days after the earthquake, as Dad often
recalled. The Long Beach earthquake struck on March 10, and did considerable
damage in Dad’s hometown, Huntington Park. Dad recalled that he got a haircut
on March 10, and the earthquake struck later that afternoon. The barber ran
into the street and was killed by a falling brick.
A few years ago when Mother was nearly 100 years old, she
recalled to me that she visited the Gilman home shortly before the wedding,
getting acquainted with her new in-laws-to-be, and shopping in preparation for
her wedding. There was a cash crisis on
that day in the Gilman household. The banks had closed, and no one knew when
they would open again. The elder Mr. Gilman needed to pay the mortgage. He
asked Virginia, very politely, if she had any money. Yes she did, and her money
was readily accessible, because she had her savings in postal savings
certificates and not in the bank. So all was well; she made the loan. In that
same phone conversation with me, Mother recalled that she spent some of her
savings on material for her wedding dress, which she took home to sew. After
the wedding the newlyweds would cash in her remaining postal savings
certificates to buy a used car.
Her visit to Huntington Park was just days before the
earthquake. This was the bottom of the Depression, as Dad liked to say. Banks
were in crisis. California banks closed on March 3, and President Roosevelt was
inaugurated on Friday the 4th. His first action was to close all
banks nationally. They would not open again until Monday the 14th,
which was after the earthquake. Mother’s visit must have been the weekend of
March 5 and 6. She finished her shopping and was back home making her dress by
March 10, so she did not experience the earthquake.
My sister Virginia recalls another earthquake story as told
by Dad. Sometime between March 10 and March 20, Mother would be baptized in
Dad’s church, the Huntington Park Christian Church. The church building had
been damaged by the earthquake. Some of the roof was open to the sky.
Nevertheless the baptistry was operational. Dad recalled, fondly, that a ray of
sunshine came through the roof and illuminated his bride-to-be just as she came
up out of the water. Dad said much later in life that this was the most
beautiful sight he had ever seen.
The pastor who performed the baptism, and the wedding
ceremony, was Kelly O’Neal. He and Mrs. O’Neal are on the right in this photo
of the wedding party at the ranch. Others from left to right are Roland
Nuckols, Hallie Westlund, Virginia and Joe, Gene Nuckols, Bill and Virgie
Byles, Sam and Mae Nuckols, and Joe and Stella Gilman. My cousin Betty
remembers the day, but she was deemed too small to make the trip from Huntington
Park. I think she is still a bit miffed about that.
Mother and Dad made their first home in Huntington Park, or
close by. Dad still worked for the Santa Fe Railway, but Santa Fe had reduced
his grade, pay and hours to keep him on the payroll throughout the Depression.
He worked half time, and Mother worked half time as a beautician. She could
have worked full time, but she thought she ought not to work more hours than
her husband. Mother recalled that their grocery budget, after all the bills
were paid, was seven dollars and change per week. They lived well on seven
dollars, she said.
Joe D. Gilman, Jr
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

