Tuesday, May 17, 2050

One. This earth is our home.

This earth is our home. Living things live here on earth. All the people live here.

People imagine life elsewhere, but we have not discovered living things on distant planets. We find life on earth everywhere. Many species thrive, but others just survive. Many have failed and given up their time and place on earth. Other species fill the empty spaces.

The earth is cluttered with artifacts. People make artifacts. Cities and wheels and books and gadgets and plowed fields and trash dumps are artifacts.

Everything that is not an artifact is a natural thing. The cosmos, the earth, and earth’s living creatures are natural things. Artifacts are lifeless things, because we do not know how to make a living thing.

Birds make nests, and beavers make dams, but these are not artifacts because they are not made by people. Our customary distinction between the natural and the artificial is part of a larger distinction between people and all other life. Some of us would say that this difference is God-ordained, and a work in progress. Others maintain that the uniqueness of people is a false conceit arising from our self-centeredness.

Biologists do not find a sharp distinctiveness in people. Our bodies are surely natural for the most part, and not so different from other primates. We do have the apparatus for vocalization, the larger brain, and refinements of the neurological system, and generally less hair, but none of those would seem to put us in a biological class apart from all other life.

To illuminate the distinctiveness of people we look to the mind. Intelligence, passion, reason, imagination, meaning, love, compassion, value, beauty and creativity reside in the mind, or as we like to say, in the hearts and minds of people. These make people unique.

We call ourselves homo sapiens, the wise ones. We might well have called ourselves the imaginative ones. Imagination is more common in people than wisdom, and other creatures may also be wise in their own ways. But no other creature has an imagination that competes with the imaginations of people. Creativity is evidence of imagination, and no other creature displays such an array of created things.

Most people live in their world of artifacts. We are dependent on nature; we may value it, seek it, visit it, import it, study it, exploit it, destroy it, defend it, preserve it or enjoy it; but no one succeeds in becoming completely again a part of nature. We look back to a time when people were thought to be closer to nature, or even part of it. But our journey is taking us in a different direction.

People make more than artifacts. We make intangible things like language, laws, literature, conversation, music, beauty, discovery and war. Of course the weapons of war and the destruction of war are artifacts, but the belligerence of war is an intangible thing created by people and residing within the mind. Similarly, laws are the intangible meaning residing in the minds of people who read words on paper. The significance of language is in its influence on and in the minds of people. Beauty is similarly an intangible influence in the mind’s eye, and music in the mind’s ear.

Monday, May 17, 2049

Two. People are creative.

People are creative. Some people are more creative than others, but people generally have the ability to produce and introduce new things, tangible or intangible. Creativity is an event originating in the mind of a person. In another context we might like to reserve the word creative for the few who produce art and innovations of enduring value. But here it is observed that creativity is a distinguishing characteristic of people, despite the fact that much created work is not valued and not remembered. Every created thing was first imagined.

One measure of human creativity is the inventory of created things, whether remembered or forgotten, tangible or intangible. For example, every word of every language is a created thing, unless perhaps it is an unmeditated accident. Then follow grammar and idiom and metaphor, and every original conversation and composition and work of literature. A criterion for creativity is that a conscious, cognitive, innovative effort of a person did produce the thing. Imagination and intuition and insight and intent give birth to innovation. The whole catalog of tangible and intangible things thus produced, if we could know it, is immense. Creativity is a cumulative work, in which most people produce only small variations on a theme, and most created things are soon lost and forgotten.

In science, truth is recognized by its quality of not being created in the mind. In art, the opposite is true.  The created thing succeeds when it truly expresses the artist’s vision.

Language, like necessity, stimulates creativity. As soon as primitive people had the grammar to say “Jake is at the lake” and “The moon is in the sky”, someone was bound to say “Jake is in the sky”. Thus language gave rise to the creative genre of the story and the fable and the lie. Humor and hypothesis would soon follow. Language stimulates the imagination. The creative mind attaches meaning to language it receives, whether or not the same meaning was intended by the originator, and whether or not it is true. Understanding the other begins with a creative effort.

Many artifacts are created things, or contain some element of creativity. The first one is created; copies of an artifact are also artifacts but not created artifacts.

A spider’s web and a bird’s nest look like artifacts, but these as we said are not artifacts because they are not made by people. But more fundamentally, are the web and nest and beaver's dam also examples of created things? The answer depends on the role of cognitive processes like imagination and innovation and intent in the minds of such animals.

Biologists assure us that a spider does not intend to build a web. A spider does not have a mind capable of forming intent. A spider is hard-wired, we might say, to perform a certain stepping and spinning choreography in response to external stimuli, and these result in the spider’s web. We may doubt that the spider envisions the web before it is built. But certainly the sight of the finished web could be a stimulus that prompts the spider to move on to other hard-wired behavior. A student of spider behavior might answer these questions.

Does a bird envision a nest before it is built? With due respect to birds, we would like to think it does. Yet it also seems plausible that the bird, like the spider, simply responds to a visual stimulus, a fork of branches, by fetching materials and inserting them round and round until it sees a nest. We might prefer to think that the bird, like one of us, envisions a nest just here and sets about to build it according to plan. To confirm this we would need to know more about the mind of a bird. How long does a bird entertain a thought before acting on it? People require time to envision, to imagine, to form intent, and indeed to think. Does a bird take time? Does a bird think?

Even if a bird does not think, it still does learn. A bird inherits a brain with a space, so to speak, that is fitted to hold a song. Upon hearing the song of its species, the bird retains and imprints that sound in that space. [Or in a new space; we have learned that bird brains grow new neurons to accomodate new notes.] Other spaces will be filled with an imprint of the parent's image, or of the migration route, or perhaps something to do with nest-building.

In any case the bird does not innovate. The plan for the nest that the bird might learn, and might consciously envision, and may even intend to build, is the one characteristic of its species. Different species build different nests, but the innovation that distinguishes them is not spontaneous in the minds of birds. And if the variety of birds’ nests results from some Darwinian process of successful but accidental innovation, or just accidental innovation, this is still not creativity, unless it is also a cognitive creativity in the mind of God.

Monday, May 18, 2048

Three. People are rational.

People are rational. Most people, most of the time, have reasons for their actions. The reasons might be based on faulty logic, or incorrect information, or superstition, or simple emulation, or strong desire, but they are reasons nonetheless. We often use the term rational to refer to an educated notion of logical, well informed, soundly based reasoning. But more broadly, rational behavior may be said to result from the application of whatever cognitive resources are available to a particular person. And what appears to you or me as an irrational phobia is the other person's considered opinion.

Rational behavior is distinguished from what is popularly called instinctive behavior. When certain external stimuli produce a consistent or predictable response, the action is said to be instinctive. The behavior of animals, and especially the lower animals, is likely to be instinctive rather than rational. The behavior of a certain species of worm is said to be fully predictable. Its response to external stimuli has been studied and fully described. A compulsive, subconscious habit in people seems akin to this predictable, unthinking response. But experts tell us that even subconscious behavior in people is learned by experience.

The behavior of people in matters of food and sex, for example, is motivated by something more primitive than rational thought, but our response even to these basic appetites is also heavily influenced by cultural norms. In fact we insist on it. Our laws and social conventions require thoughtful and conforming behavior. Nonconforming behavior is unacceptable when it is thoughtless or instinctive, and even more unacceptable when it is premeditated.

We learn from experience that bees can sting. We learn to draw back immediately from a buzzing bee. Our reaction to the bee is directed by our subconscious mind. We do not need to think, consciously and rationally, that the bee must be avoided because it might sting. Yet when asked why we drew back suddenly and spilled the drink, we give a reason for our action: There was a bee on my hand. In this sense our actions are nearly all rational. We have our reasons, and we know what they are. If asked for a reason, we can supply one.

Sunday, May 19, 2047

Four. Every person has a unique outlook.

Every person has a unique mind, and a unique outlook. The outlook animates the personality, and the outlook informs our thoughts and words and actions. To know another person is to know something of her outlook. The thoughtfully considered outlook of a philosopher has been called a worldview. But let us define outlook by saying that everybody has one.

People acquire information through observation. Observation is defined broadly as all means of learning. Information, broadly, is the content thus acquired. Information includes the logical framework or the habits of mind that associate bits of information, to the extent that these are learned. A person’s outlook reflects acquired information, learned habits of mind, and innate characteristics of that person’s mind and body.

Love and trust are part of a person’s outlook. The object of love or trust may be selected by process as innate as childbirth, or by the more deliberate process of observation. In personal relationships, observation will be understood to include the whole experience of the other, and every fact and image and impression that the experience introduces to the mind. The distinction between passive or objective observation and lived experience is often blurred. Objective observation is a learned discipline, and a very useful one in science for example, but here we will not assume that observation and experience are always distinct. Both are means of learning. Both inform the outlook. The mind does not necessarily deconvolute the two.

In summary, observation refers to everything brought to the mind by the senses. The senses inform the mind, and the mind forms its outlook. Sight and hearing, language and music, color and shape and dimension, pain and trauma, scent and touch and embrace influence the mind through the senses. Observation in this general sense may be a shared and interactive experience, rather than a private or passive one.

Information resides in the mind. Of course we could speak of information lying forgotten in a book, or information waiting to be discovered in the physical world. But the information that informs the outlook resides in the mind. Information is taken to encompass a broad spectrum of things that can (in some circumstance) be consciously recalled, from salient facts to ideas and impressions and logic and associations. All these things are learned, if they are acquired through the senses.

In the creative act, the mind acquires an idea, or a vision, that is not delivered by the senses. Perhaps it is a simple thing, a variation on a common theme, a designer’s new line, a new hypothesis on cause and effect. But it is original; its source is not purely observation but also imagination.

Sunday, May 20, 2046

Five. A lion waits.

A lion waits in tall grass for the approaching prey. At some moment she will spring and chase. Intuitively we doubt that the lion’s action is instinctive, like a spider’s rushing toward the motion of a trapped fly. We suppose that the lion deliberates much as we would in deciding when to act.

We might suppose that the lion gives chase when she can imagine a successful chase. Informed by experience and the senses, the lion envisions the chase before she springs. We could describe this envisioning with language that describes a human athlete’s performance. The athlete imagines clearing the bar, envisioning the required action in space and time, and then acting. We cannot really know what it is like to be a lion, but it is tempting to believe that the lion, like one of us, is a conscious being with mental apparatus that envisions the action before taking it. Then the lion must have an imagination, however limited. The development of skill requires imagination, just as creativity requires imagination.

If the lion has no imagination whatever, and cannot envision the action before taking it, then she must simply react when some accumulation of stimuli reaches a tipping point. The stimuli might include sight, scent and sound; motion, size, speed, proximity, separation, and so forth. This gives us a quite different and less appealing idea of what it is like to be a lion. Even a worm responds to stimuli. A clever observer might develop an algorithm that predicts what a lion will do in response to such stimuli. The algorithm would be useful in building a robotic lion, but we would doubt that the real lion is like our robot.

There is a middle way, in which the lion learns from experience but still perhaps does not imagine or think about the action before taking it. The lion retains in its subconscious mind an image of conditions preceding every chase, and that image is associated with success or failure in the chase. The lion’s internal “springing algorithm” is created and modified and fine-tuned by all of its experience. Yet this educated lion still springs when immediate stimuli tell it to spring. Imagination and decision may have no role. Conscious thought may have little or no role. And this model would also describe many of the actions of people as well. Like other animals, we learn by association of the outcome with the conditions leading up to the outcome. This is the way we learn about the stinging bee.

The middle way is probably closest to the truth, but still we do not know what it is like to be a lion. The middle way describes the way people behave in many situations, even when they imagine they are being thoughtful and logical.

Saturday, May 20, 2045

Six. Chipping stone for millions of years.

Hominids, we are told, have been chipping stone for millions of years. Their product for millions of years was something like an ax without a handle. The hand ax functioned as an extension of tooth and claw, or tooth and nail, and became necessary for the creature’s survival. The stone tool was very crude at first. Stone-chipping skills improved slowly, over many thousands of generations, until rather handsome hand axes were being produced toward the end of the era.

Stone-chipping skill requires the conscious foresight that we have called a primitive imagination. Striking the work just here, with the anvil held just so, will remove a flake that advances the shape toward the envisioned end product. Having envisioned the blow, the primate must execute it with effective hand-eye coordination learned by experience. To envision the action, and the result of the action, and then to perform it, is a definition of skill. For a very long period of time there is evidence of the gradual development of skill in hominids. There is little concurrent evidence of creativity, with its greater demands on the imagination.

We may doubt that the refinements of stone axes in the later period were necessary for Darwinian survival of the species. We are free to imagine that a stone-chipping hominid produced a well-made piece, like some we have found, because he had the skills to do so, and because he rather liked the result. His fellow primates may have liked the result as well, and rewarded his efforts. A little imagination, plus requisite skill, produced an artifact that was valued for reasons other than simple functionality. We call this art. We recognize such later pieces today as tools made with great skill to achieve an imagined ideal form and appearance. The craftsman was proud of his work.

We can be sure these tools were not produced by rote, like the spider’s web or the bird’s nest. We know what it is like to be a toolmaker. He may have been mute and dull, but he focused on his work and made each blow different from the last, as he thought necessary to produce the form he desired.

Again, birds build nests, but birds do not innovate. Nests of a species are like the nests of the previous generation. Change is glacial. Birds do not imagine new designs or introduce new techniques into their nest-building.

Similarly we are given to understand that the early makers of stone axes did not innovate or invent. So far as we know they did not make a spear head and attach it to a shaft. They did not make shell necklaces or bone sewing needles. They did not carve figurines or decorate objects. They did not bury their dead. Evidence of these higher levels of imagination and innovation and creativity belongs to a relatively recent time. An expansion of art and artifacts began some tens of thousands of years ago and is still continuing. The capable imaginations which produced this variety of found artifacts probably developed (experts currently believe) from a small beginning in Africa during the preceding hundred thousand years or so. This period is associated with the rise of modern man, Homo sapiens. It is associated with the advent of people.

Saturday, May 21, 2044

Seven. She knows what she likes.

Why does the female of some avian species prefer the red-feathered male? Biologists answer with a story about chemistry. His red-feathered display produces a response in the retina of the eye of the female that sends chemical signals to her brain, causing her to behave in a receptive way that produces more red-feathered males, and more susceptible females. An engineer might call this a stable feedback loop. Once begun, the cyclic phenomenon tends to reinforce and perpetuate itself. Red reinforces red in the life cycle of the species. Others might call it sexual selection. She knows what she likes.

How did the ability to speak develop in those early stone-chippers with their limited imaginations? We are delightfully free to speculate, because there is so little hard evidence as to why or even when people began to speak. Could it be that the female of the species, or the male, simply liked and responded to the sound of vocalization? Is it not still true that spoken sounds in an intimate or social setting are an attractive or seductive or influential characteristic of a person? Could it be that the variety of sounds once even exceeded the variety of meaningful words? Did speech emerge as art and music before grammatical communication became necessary to survival? Did the anatomy for speech result from sexual selection of those who made music and small talk?

And finally, is preference in the mind of a person, or a community, simply a matter of deterministic chemistry, as it is reported to be in simpler species? In answer to this question, materialists would say yes. Dissenters would say no, there is also an immaterial dimension to the human mind. In other words, there is no accounting for taste. We do not need anything in our genetic code telling us to prefer the red or the blue or the tall and dark or the skillful or the creative. Our individual and community tastes are conditioned by far more than genetics. Yet tastes could still influence genetics through sexual selection.